1 00:00:13,560 --> 00:00:15,639 Tell me the truth. Tell me the truth. 2 00:00:15,640 --> 00:00:18,359 Tell me the truth. 3 00:00:18,360 --> 00:00:20,359 Tell me the truth. 4 00:00:33,440 --> 00:00:35,400 - Hello? - 'It's Phil.' 5 00:00:36,400 --> 00:00:38,320 Oh. Good morning. 6 00:00:42,400 --> 00:00:44,399 Someone's keen. 7 00:00:44,400 --> 00:00:46,519 I tried to call first. 8 00:00:46,520 --> 00:00:48,720 It was a long shower. 9 00:00:49,024 --> 00:00:50,824 What's going on? 10 00:00:52,120 --> 00:00:54,439 Tom Mackie has overdosed. 11 00:00:54,440 --> 00:00:55,840 What? 12 00:00:57,167 --> 00:00:58,142 Dead? 13 00:00:58,143 --> 00:01:01,199 No, but hospitalised. 14 00:01:01,200 --> 00:01:03,719 - There was a break-in, too. - At the same time? 15 00:01:03,720 --> 00:01:07,639 Yeah. I'm going over there now. To Glasgow. 16 00:01:07,640 --> 00:01:09,670 Right. I'm coming with you. Just... 17 00:01:10,640 --> 00:01:12,399 let me put some clothes on. 18 00:01:12,400 --> 00:01:13,799 You don't want to go like that? 19 00:01:24,280 --> 00:01:26,801 - Around 11:30, we arrived. - You disturbed them? 20 00:01:26,826 --> 00:01:28,639 I saw the shape of someone through the front window, 21 00:01:28,640 --> 00:01:30,359 but once we'd got in, they were gone. 22 00:01:30,360 --> 00:01:33,359 Some footprints in the grass and in the soil at the back. 23 00:01:33,360 --> 00:01:35,399 Residential street back there? 24 00:01:35,400 --> 00:01:37,759 We had a look for cameras. Couldn't see any, but... 25 00:01:37,760 --> 00:01:39,056 We'll do another scan. 26 00:01:42,320 --> 00:01:45,199 We should have arrested him yesterday. 27 00:01:45,200 --> 00:01:47,951 - This wouldn't have happened. - We didn't have enough. 28 00:01:50,932 --> 00:01:52,812 Do you think we pushed him to this? 29 00:01:54,575 --> 00:01:58,131 It might not have been intentional, or even self-inflicted. 30 00:01:58,400 --> 00:01:59,680 What do you mean? 31 00:01:59,840 --> 00:02:01,639 Well, it's quite a coincidence, isn't it? 32 00:02:01,640 --> 00:02:04,639 An overdose and a break-in at the same time. 33 00:02:04,640 --> 00:02:08,175 Was someone trying to kill him and make it look like a suicide? 34 00:02:09,920 --> 00:02:11,604 - Is that his mobile? - Yep. 35 00:02:11,605 --> 00:02:15,479 Last calls were to the police, his ex-wife Elena and... 36 00:02:15,480 --> 00:02:18,480 another name. Alex Gilbey. 37 00:02:21,375 --> 00:02:25,615 Tell them, as soon as Mr Mackie wakes up, we want to speak to him. 38 00:02:28,040 --> 00:02:30,080 Have you heard from Tom? 39 00:02:31,680 --> 00:02:34,200 - No. - I thought he'd at least send a text. 40 00:02:35,613 --> 00:02:37,696 You nearly died, Weird. 41 00:02:38,440 --> 00:02:40,759 I'm done with this. All of this. 42 00:02:40,760 --> 00:02:43,959 We made a pact. A promise. Don't break that now. 43 00:02:43,960 --> 00:02:45,524 What's in it for me, eh? 44 00:02:46,325 --> 00:02:48,722 You two boys are the ones with all the secrets. 45 00:02:48,925 --> 00:02:51,639 Except the drugs and the car. 46 00:02:51,640 --> 00:02:53,679 Well, they know about that now, so... 47 00:02:53,680 --> 00:02:55,882 We still need to protect Alex. 48 00:02:56,360 --> 00:03:00,182 Alex. Right. It's all about Alex. 49 00:03:00,207 --> 00:03:04,280 Everyone loves Alex. That's always been the problem, hasn't it? 50 00:03:07,811 --> 00:03:10,171 You know he's never gonna love you back, right? 51 00:03:11,687 --> 00:03:14,727 You think I'm stupid. That I didn't see what was going on. 52 00:03:16,398 --> 00:03:19,559 The only reason you invited Rosie to that party 53 00:03:19,560 --> 00:03:21,772 was because you wanted to impress him. 54 00:03:22,125 --> 00:03:24,039 What did you think would happen? 55 00:03:24,040 --> 00:03:27,560 That he would suddenly realise you were the one all along? 56 00:03:29,520 --> 00:03:30,880 I know, Ziggy. 57 00:03:32,720 --> 00:03:34,360 Of course I know. 58 00:03:37,416 --> 00:03:39,439 I was waiting for you to tell me, but... 59 00:03:39,440 --> 00:03:41,099 Ah, come on, Ziggy, don't leave. 60 00:03:41,100 --> 00:03:43,080 I've got to go. 61 00:03:46,760 --> 00:03:48,239 What did you do that for? 62 00:03:48,240 --> 00:03:50,759 You're stringing him along. It's cruel. 63 00:03:50,760 --> 00:03:51,879 We're friends, Weird, 64 00:03:51,880 --> 00:03:55,000 and, actually, you're the one that's always baiting him, teasing him. 65 00:03:56,480 --> 00:03:58,880 Then why haven't you told him about you and Lynn? 66 00:04:00,047 --> 00:04:02,820 You've spent the whole summer talking to her. 67 00:04:03,562 --> 00:04:05,073 What, you don't want to break his heart? 68 00:04:05,098 --> 00:04:07,310 - There's nothing going on with me and Lynn. - Do you think I'm slow? 69 00:04:07,335 --> 00:04:09,461 - Nothing happened. - Stop lying to me, Alex. 70 00:04:11,170 --> 00:04:14,287 Keeping it secret, just like you kept you and Rosie secret... 71 00:04:14,288 --> 00:04:15,387 Stop it, Weird. 72 00:04:15,388 --> 00:04:17,359 Everybody loves Alex. 73 00:04:17,360 --> 00:04:20,260 It's all about Alex, and look how that ends up... 74 00:04:20,261 --> 00:04:23,213 Shut up! OK?! 75 00:04:23,376 --> 00:04:25,776 - Mint. - Sarge, I just heard from the lab. 76 00:04:25,801 --> 00:04:27,270 'Carpet fibres from the cardigan?' 77 00:04:27,271 --> 00:04:31,274 No. Yes, I mean, yes, but, no, there's something else. 78 00:04:31,275 --> 00:04:32,289 What? 79 00:04:32,774 --> 00:04:35,986 They've found semen on the cuff of the cardigan. 80 00:04:36,469 --> 00:04:39,891 What? Whose? Did they cross-check it with...? 81 00:04:39,892 --> 00:04:41,190 It's Alex Gilbey's. 82 00:04:41,470 --> 00:04:44,025 'Alex Gilbey's semen is on the cardigan.' 83 00:04:44,312 --> 00:04:48,025 Jesus Christ. OK. We're coming back now. 84 00:04:49,161 --> 00:04:51,253 - I heard. - Oh, my God. 85 00:04:51,663 --> 00:04:54,201 It was Alex she went to see at the party... 86 00:04:55,066 --> 00:04:56,685 ...and we have proof. 87 00:05:13,530 --> 00:05:16,459 Alex Gilbey. I am arresting you under Section 1 88 00:05:16,484 --> 00:05:18,898 of the Criminal Justice Scotland Act 2016 89 00:05:18,899 --> 00:05:20,803 - for the murder of Rosie Duff. - What? 90 00:05:20,804 --> 00:05:22,403 You are not obliged to say anything, 91 00:05:22,404 --> 00:05:24,882 but anything you do say will be noted and may be used in evidence. 92 00:05:24,883 --> 00:05:26,390 No, I can't leave. I've just had a baby. 93 00:05:26,391 --> 00:05:27,940 - Do you understand? - 'Alex?' 94 00:05:27,964 --> 00:05:31,683 Please. Look. I'll co-operate in any way you need, but not this. 95 00:05:31,684 --> 00:05:32,803 - Alex! - Please! 96 00:05:32,804 --> 00:05:35,094 Let them put the handcuffs on you. We'll make sure your wife is OK. 97 00:05:35,095 --> 00:05:37,563 - What are you doing?! - I'm sorry. It'll be OK. 98 00:05:37,564 --> 00:05:40,003 - This way, Alex. - You can't take him! Please. 99 00:05:40,004 --> 00:05:42,484 - Alex. - I'll be back. 100 00:06:10,084 --> 00:06:12,924 ? Dig us up and hold us high 101 00:06:15,044 --> 00:06:17,644 ? Raise our carcass to the sky 102 00:06:19,564 --> 00:06:22,284 ? Wrap us up in sequin skin 103 00:06:24,524 --> 00:06:28,044 ? And we can dance again in sin 104 00:06:30,764 --> 00:06:33,323 ? Just take my hand and be brave 105 00:06:33,324 --> 00:06:35,563 ? We'll say goodbye to this grave 106 00:06:35,564 --> 00:06:37,763 ? Tonight, we salsa, we rave 107 00:06:37,764 --> 00:06:40,803 ? We are upcycled and saved 108 00:06:40,804 --> 00:06:43,003 ? We've got the hay, so let's roll 109 00:06:43,004 --> 00:06:45,283 ? Surrender all self-control 110 00:06:45,284 --> 00:06:47,963 ? Quick now, before the bell tolls 111 00:06:47,964 --> 00:06:51,164 ? Let's sing the sighs From our souls... ? 112 00:06:51,169 --> 00:06:54,169 *CREDITS* 113 00:07:02,985 --> 00:07:04,803 What did you do last night, Alex? 114 00:07:04,804 --> 00:07:06,203 Last night? 115 00:07:06,204 --> 00:07:09,816 You've brought Mr Gilbey in under charges relating to 1996. 116 00:07:09,841 --> 00:07:12,064 - Why do you need to know about last night? - You don't need to answer. 117 00:07:12,065 --> 00:07:13,384 I was at home. 118 00:07:13,585 --> 00:07:15,504 - Did you leave the house at all? - No. 119 00:07:15,505 --> 00:07:16,584 Make any phone calls? 120 00:07:16,585 --> 00:07:18,545 You took my phone, so you'll have to check. 121 00:07:19,069 --> 00:07:20,705 You spoke to Tom Mackie. 122 00:07:21,902 --> 00:07:24,104 - He's my friend. - What did you speak about? 123 00:07:24,105 --> 00:07:25,904 What has that got to do with anything? 124 00:07:25,905 --> 00:07:27,384 Did you go over there and see Tom 125 00:07:27,385 --> 00:07:29,464 after your conversation last night, Alex? 126 00:07:29,465 --> 00:07:30,705 No. 127 00:07:32,905 --> 00:07:34,105 Why? 128 00:07:37,425 --> 00:07:39,145 What's happened? 129 00:07:43,145 --> 00:07:45,744 Your friend has been admitted to hospital. 130 00:07:45,745 --> 00:07:48,064 He's in a medically induced coma 131 00:07:48,065 --> 00:07:50,784 after mixing several anti-anxiety medications, 132 00:07:50,785 --> 00:07:53,741 sleeping pills and alcohol. 133 00:07:54,025 --> 00:07:56,052 You need to tell my wife. Lynn. 134 00:07:56,053 --> 00:07:59,264 You need to tell her. He's her brother. 135 00:07:59,265 --> 00:08:00,892 Your wife has been informed. 136 00:08:02,614 --> 00:08:03,854 Is he OK? 137 00:08:06,243 --> 00:08:08,069 Is he gonna be OK? 138 00:08:08,745 --> 00:08:10,385 We don't know yet. 139 00:08:13,821 --> 00:08:15,934 Did you threaten Tom Mackie, Alex? 140 00:08:15,959 --> 00:08:17,479 - What? - Did you threaten him? 141 00:08:17,905 --> 00:08:19,904 Did you go over there and tell him not to talk to us? 142 00:08:19,905 --> 00:08:24,265 No. You were worried he'd tell us about your relationship with Rosie. 143 00:08:26,025 --> 00:08:27,505 No. 144 00:08:29,345 --> 00:08:30,785 We didn't have a relationship. 145 00:08:34,665 --> 00:08:35,825 Hmm. 146 00:08:43,945 --> 00:08:46,185 Do you recognise that cardigan, Alex? 147 00:08:48,945 --> 00:08:50,145 It's Rosie's. 148 00:08:51,505 --> 00:08:53,224 She was wearing it the night she died. 149 00:08:53,225 --> 00:08:55,665 But you knew that, didn't you? Because you were with her. 150 00:09:02,345 --> 00:09:05,104 There was so much of Rosie's blood on the cardigan 151 00:09:05,105 --> 00:09:07,424 that the amount of female DNA present 152 00:09:07,425 --> 00:09:11,226 masked a small amount of male DNA on the cuff. 153 00:09:11,425 --> 00:09:14,105 They missed that in 1996. But we didn't. 154 00:09:17,505 --> 00:09:19,730 The DNA is from semen, Alex. 155 00:09:20,430 --> 00:09:22,385 And it's a match for you. 156 00:09:36,358 --> 00:09:38,506 I didn't kill her. 157 00:09:39,785 --> 00:09:41,715 I didn't do anything to her, 158 00:09:42,191 --> 00:09:44,087 I would never hurt her. 159 00:09:44,346 --> 00:09:45,916 I couldn't have. 160 00:09:46,105 --> 00:09:49,563 Tell us what really happened, Alex. That's all we want. 161 00:09:49,865 --> 00:09:51,346 You don't have to say anything. 162 00:09:51,347 --> 00:09:54,095 If you didn't kill her, Alex, you must really want to know who did. 163 00:09:54,096 --> 00:09:56,469 - Of course I do. - With this new evidence, 164 00:09:56,470 --> 00:09:59,029 the best thing you can do is explain. 165 00:09:59,055 --> 00:10:02,425 If you say nothing, it will just look worse for you. 166 00:10:13,585 --> 00:10:15,114 I was seeing her. 167 00:10:16,247 --> 00:10:19,785 I was in love with her. She didn't want anyone to know. 168 00:10:20,065 --> 00:10:21,739 It was this secretive thing. 169 00:10:22,089 --> 00:10:24,384 We used to write notes to each other. 170 00:10:24,385 --> 00:10:26,028 Meet after her shift. 171 00:10:27,394 --> 00:10:28,895 But in public... 172 00:10:31,745 --> 00:10:33,185 ...she'd ignore me. 173 00:10:34,889 --> 00:10:36,639 Did that make you angry? 174 00:10:38,764 --> 00:10:40,044 No! 175 00:10:44,065 --> 00:10:45,585 No. 176 00:10:46,822 --> 00:10:48,110 It made me sad. 177 00:10:49,412 --> 00:10:50,612 Like... 178 00:10:51,465 --> 00:10:53,153 Like I wasn't good enough. 179 00:10:55,665 --> 00:10:56,905 Ziggy knew. 180 00:10:58,945 --> 00:11:00,184 Rosie. 181 00:11:00,185 --> 00:11:01,784 He's a good guy. 182 00:11:01,785 --> 00:11:03,692 I know he is. Why do you think I like him? 183 00:11:03,693 --> 00:11:05,348 What's going on? 184 00:11:05,349 --> 00:11:08,367 Just tell him one way or another, will you? 185 00:11:15,225 --> 00:11:16,838 Well, he's protective. 186 00:11:17,309 --> 00:11:20,625 Don't worry, don't... Don't listen to him. 187 00:11:21,741 --> 00:11:24,440 - I can't stay long. - Why did you come down, then? 188 00:11:26,864 --> 00:11:28,605 - To do that. - Come inside. 189 00:11:28,606 --> 00:11:30,185 - I can't. - No, not yet, not yet. 190 00:11:31,905 --> 00:11:32,968 I've got an idea. 191 00:11:48,205 --> 00:11:50,618 I know that I haven't been straight-forward. 192 00:11:54,225 --> 00:11:57,985 It's not cos I change my mind. I never change my mind about you. 193 00:11:58,918 --> 00:12:02,422 So what is it? Is there someone else? 194 00:12:03,265 --> 00:12:04,438 No. 195 00:12:09,933 --> 00:12:12,342 I feel like maybe I just have to get out of here. 196 00:12:12,625 --> 00:12:14,591 I don't want to, because you're here, 197 00:12:14,592 --> 00:12:16,225 but I just feel so stuck... 198 00:12:17,665 --> 00:12:20,344 ...in the pub, in this town, in my family. 199 00:12:20,345 --> 00:12:21,705 Don't go anywhere. 200 00:12:23,145 --> 00:12:24,985 I've been other places, they're all shite. 201 00:12:29,225 --> 00:12:30,489 Wait, are we...? 202 00:12:31,888 --> 00:12:33,480 Are we on again? 203 00:12:34,145 --> 00:12:35,225 Or off? 204 00:12:36,271 --> 00:12:38,951 - This feels like we're off. - I don't know. 205 00:12:43,785 --> 00:12:45,504 - I've got to go. - What kind of answer is that? 206 00:12:45,505 --> 00:12:46,985 Do you really need one? 207 00:12:51,465 --> 00:12:53,224 I'm starting to think you're ashamed of me. 208 00:12:53,225 --> 00:12:54,704 No! It's not that... 209 00:12:54,705 --> 00:12:56,051 You don't want anyone to know about us. 210 00:12:56,052 --> 00:12:57,464 Won't be seen with me. 211 00:12:57,465 --> 00:12:59,670 Say it's about your brothers. Your family won't approve. 212 00:12:59,671 --> 00:13:01,395 - It's not that... - Why won't they approve of me? 213 00:13:01,396 --> 00:13:03,745 - It's not about you, it's about me. - Are you sure? 214 00:13:05,135 --> 00:13:07,215 Cos it feels kinda racist, you know? 215 00:13:08,613 --> 00:13:10,813 - What? - Well, prove to me that it's not. 216 00:13:10,960 --> 00:13:13,417 - Take me home right now. - You don't know them at all. 217 00:13:13,418 --> 00:13:14,932 What else am I supposed to think? 218 00:13:14,933 --> 00:13:17,729 You're supposed to listen to me and trust me when I say it's not that. 219 00:13:17,730 --> 00:13:20,422 Give me one good reason to trust you when you always disappear. 220 00:13:20,423 --> 00:13:22,720 - Screw you, Alex. - See, there you go again. 221 00:13:24,185 --> 00:13:25,620 Screw you! 222 00:13:32,865 --> 00:13:34,865 That was the last time I saw her. 223 00:13:37,540 --> 00:13:39,980 And then she walked off into town at 2am? 224 00:13:41,788 --> 00:13:43,308 Did you follow her? 225 00:13:44,745 --> 00:13:45,905 No. 226 00:13:47,539 --> 00:13:49,034 I wish I did. 227 00:13:50,781 --> 00:13:52,610 I wish I begged her to stay. 228 00:13:53,665 --> 00:13:55,537 I wish I held onto her. 229 00:13:55,981 --> 00:13:57,693 Why didn't you tell the police any of this? 230 00:13:57,694 --> 00:14:01,976 Because we made a decision. Well, Ziggy made a decision. 231 00:14:02,225 --> 00:14:05,264 He knew about Rosie and me. He knew how bad it looked. 232 00:14:05,265 --> 00:14:06,671 He told you to lie? 233 00:14:07,515 --> 00:14:09,566 He saw how the police treated me. 234 00:14:10,148 --> 00:14:13,344 He saw the way they grabbed hold of me when they arrested us. 235 00:14:13,345 --> 00:14:15,289 Get off! 236 00:14:15,627 --> 00:14:17,246 He was scared for me. 237 00:14:18,423 --> 00:14:20,025 Scared they'd pin it on me. 238 00:14:21,105 --> 00:14:22,825 Because of your race? 239 00:14:25,431 --> 00:14:30,511 That fear isn't exactly unfounded, Sergeant. 240 00:14:33,377 --> 00:14:35,817 Once I'd lied, I couldn't change my story. 241 00:14:36,137 --> 00:14:37,777 It would only look bad. 242 00:14:39,234 --> 00:14:42,476 The choice I made when I was 21 and drunk... 243 00:14:46,034 --> 00:14:48,347 ...it's affected the rest of my life. 244 00:14:55,152 --> 00:14:57,384 I'm going to be speaking with a senior officer 245 00:14:57,385 --> 00:14:59,944 and seeking authority to extend your detention period 246 00:14:59,945 --> 00:15:02,345 - to the maximum of 24 hours. - No! 247 00:15:04,162 --> 00:15:06,654 You were the last person to see her alive, Alex. 248 00:15:06,825 --> 00:15:08,404 I cannot let you go yet. 249 00:15:11,745 --> 00:15:13,529 - How'd it go? - Well... 250 00:15:14,145 --> 00:15:16,905 I got him to admit that he had a relationship with Rosie. 251 00:15:17,093 --> 00:15:18,277 Wow. 252 00:15:20,505 --> 00:15:23,424 But he said that she left him at 2am. 253 00:15:23,425 --> 00:15:26,144 - He didn't see her after that. - Right... 254 00:15:26,145 --> 00:15:27,504 I've spoken to forensics. 255 00:15:27,505 --> 00:15:30,144 They've looked at the carpet fibres on her cardigan, 256 00:15:30,145 --> 00:15:32,464 but they still need a car to cross-check them with. 257 00:15:32,465 --> 00:15:35,545 They told me to check the International Car Carpet Database. 258 00:15:37,345 --> 00:15:38,784 Well, there obviously isn't one. 259 00:15:38,785 --> 00:15:40,585 Yeah, I know that now. 260 00:15:42,505 --> 00:15:44,144 Right, OK, well, so... 261 00:15:44,912 --> 00:15:47,104 we still need a make and a model 262 00:15:47,105 --> 00:15:48,527 - before we can see if they match? - Yeah. 263 00:15:48,528 --> 00:15:50,842 There is a second car that we don't have. 264 00:15:50,843 --> 00:15:52,725 A second crime scene that we don't know about. 265 00:15:52,726 --> 00:15:54,278 And we have... 266 00:15:54,279 --> 00:15:58,544 21... ish hours to try and build a case against Alex Gilbey. 267 00:15:58,545 --> 00:16:00,081 If there even is one. 268 00:16:00,082 --> 00:16:01,954 And your girlfriend's here. 269 00:16:01,955 --> 00:16:03,350 Girlfriend? 270 00:16:08,717 --> 00:16:10,437 Champagne, I think. 271 00:16:11,053 --> 00:16:12,184 What? 272 00:16:12,185 --> 00:16:14,178 - The drink you're gonna buy me. - Steady on. 273 00:16:14,179 --> 00:16:17,185 It's the least you can do. I've got an eyewitness. 274 00:16:17,984 --> 00:16:22,104 - Already? - Hm. The power of podcasts. 275 00:16:22,425 --> 00:16:24,064 - Are they credible? - I think so. 276 00:16:24,065 --> 00:16:25,145 Send me the details. 277 00:16:25,519 --> 00:16:26,775 What do I get in return? 278 00:16:26,776 --> 00:16:29,343 - You can have a Prosecco. - I'm serious, Karen. 279 00:16:29,344 --> 00:16:32,465 Let me in. I heard you made an arrest. 280 00:16:33,465 --> 00:16:34,705 How do you know that? 281 00:16:35,037 --> 00:16:36,665 I'm good at my job. 282 00:16:37,552 --> 00:16:38,916 Name for a name? 283 00:16:39,465 --> 00:16:41,184 You know I can't do that. 284 00:16:41,185 --> 00:16:42,945 You've got to give me something, Karen. 285 00:16:46,791 --> 00:16:48,230 How about... 286 00:16:51,705 --> 00:16:53,128 ...thank you? 287 00:16:57,222 --> 00:16:58,544 I'm going to cry! 288 00:16:58,545 --> 00:17:00,541 Oh, just text me a name and piss off. 289 00:17:02,505 --> 00:17:03,665 Swoosh. 290 00:17:16,545 --> 00:17:19,774 I was a taxi driver for 33 years. 291 00:17:19,799 --> 00:17:21,639 Not good for the back, that. 292 00:17:21,825 --> 00:17:24,718 If Suzanne hadn't made me stop, I'd still be out there, 293 00:17:24,719 --> 00:17:27,867 humped over the steering wheel. The Hunchback of Glenrothes. 294 00:17:29,041 --> 00:17:32,184 And you were driving the cab on the morning in question? 295 00:17:32,305 --> 00:17:34,707 27th June 1996. 296 00:17:34,905 --> 00:17:39,344 It was about 2:15 in the morning. Japanese golf tourists. 297 00:17:39,345 --> 00:17:41,554 They were staying in a B&B on Prentiss Road. 298 00:17:41,555 --> 00:17:44,438 - Right... - And I was waiting for them outside, 299 00:17:44,439 --> 00:17:47,824 and I seen this girl, on her own, which I thought was strange. 300 00:17:47,825 --> 00:17:50,384 Who's letting her walk home on her own at that time? 301 00:17:50,385 --> 00:17:52,384 And how clearly did you see her? 302 00:17:52,385 --> 00:17:55,465 Well, she was only a couple of metres away. Even nodded hello. 303 00:17:56,085 --> 00:17:57,561 Right. And then... 304 00:17:57,562 --> 00:18:00,144 She passes me, and then it starts to rain. 305 00:18:00,145 --> 00:18:01,664 The heavens just open. 306 00:18:01,665 --> 00:18:04,987 So she pulls up her hood, and then a car pulls up beside her. 307 00:18:05,345 --> 00:18:06,913 What sort of car? 308 00:18:06,914 --> 00:18:11,465 It was a BMW. Erm... 3 Series, I think. Older body shape. 309 00:18:12,114 --> 00:18:15,714 And, er... it was grey, could've been black. 310 00:18:17,785 --> 00:18:19,205 That's specific. 311 00:18:19,206 --> 00:18:21,591 Pretty sure it was a 325i. 312 00:18:21,592 --> 00:18:24,183 What can I say? I like cars. 313 00:18:26,545 --> 00:18:28,265 Why didn't you go to the police with this? 314 00:18:28,570 --> 00:18:29,705 I did. 315 00:18:30,056 --> 00:18:31,048 You did? 316 00:18:31,049 --> 00:18:33,845 It took me a while to realise it was her. 317 00:18:34,265 --> 00:18:37,464 I didn't follow the case much to begin with. 318 00:18:37,665 --> 00:18:42,011 I was working nights, slept all day. World passed me by. 319 00:18:42,185 --> 00:18:43,744 So, what changed? 320 00:18:43,745 --> 00:18:47,167 I saw a picture of her somewhere, and then I told my wife. 321 00:18:47,192 --> 00:18:49,541 And she realised that your account might be relevant. 322 00:18:49,566 --> 00:18:50,363 Uh-huh. 323 00:18:50,441 --> 00:18:53,064 Right. So, the car stops alongside her? 324 00:18:53,065 --> 00:18:56,527 She takes one look at the driver, she keeps on walking. 325 00:18:56,721 --> 00:19:00,384 So he starts kerb-crawling, and he's talking to her. 326 00:19:00,385 --> 00:19:01,664 Pestering? 327 00:19:01,665 --> 00:19:02,904 I wondered. 328 00:19:03,785 --> 00:19:07,224 But then she stops, and they talk for a little while. 329 00:19:07,225 --> 00:19:08,728 And did she get in the car? 330 00:19:08,729 --> 00:19:11,291 - After a while, she did. - And they drove away? 331 00:19:11,292 --> 00:19:12,192 Uh-huh. 332 00:19:12,193 --> 00:19:15,104 - So, did you see the driver? - Briefly. 333 00:19:15,105 --> 00:19:16,264 Age? 334 00:19:16,265 --> 00:19:17,664 Not sure. 335 00:19:17,665 --> 00:19:18,646 Ethnicity? 336 00:19:18,945 --> 00:19:20,175 White. 337 00:19:21,917 --> 00:19:23,981 - Are you certain? - Aye. 338 00:19:26,274 --> 00:19:28,434 - Was there anyone else in the car? - No. 339 00:19:29,317 --> 00:19:31,350 Do you remember who you spoke to at the police? 340 00:19:31,351 --> 00:19:33,590 I called the station, spoke to a receptionist, 341 00:19:33,591 --> 00:19:35,255 and she put me on to an older guy. 342 00:19:35,369 --> 00:19:37,853 - DI Barney MacLennan? - Could have been. 343 00:19:38,446 --> 00:19:40,379 And you told him everything you've told me? 344 00:19:40,404 --> 00:19:42,724 - Uh-huh. - And the police never got back to you? 345 00:19:42,889 --> 00:19:44,569 Figured it wasn't relevant. 346 00:19:48,031 --> 00:19:50,550 So, why did you call the podcast? 347 00:19:50,551 --> 00:19:53,777 Oh, that wasn't me. That was my daughter. She's a listener. 348 00:19:53,802 --> 00:19:55,083 Is it any good? 349 00:19:55,108 --> 00:19:58,173 Hmm. I'm still making my mind up about that one. 350 00:20:08,898 --> 00:20:11,556 - Have you got a minute, Sir? - Aye. Take a seat. 351 00:20:14,911 --> 00:20:16,538 Where is that, Sir? 352 00:20:17,002 --> 00:20:19,270 Oh, Loch Leven. 353 00:20:19,271 --> 00:20:21,031 I get away there, fishing. 354 00:20:21,260 --> 00:20:24,205 You're giving yourself breaks on this, aren't you, Karen? 355 00:20:24,371 --> 00:20:26,666 - Taking your weekends. - Yes, Sir, when I can. 356 00:20:26,691 --> 00:20:28,551 Cos it's hard going, cases like this. 357 00:20:28,996 --> 00:20:31,756 You can lose yourself in them. And this one in particular... 358 00:20:32,511 --> 00:20:33,802 Do I look tired, Sir? 359 00:20:33,827 --> 00:20:35,927 No, no. No, it's just I... 360 00:20:35,952 --> 00:20:37,631 I know you're committed, 361 00:20:38,076 --> 00:20:40,316 and I know what that takes. I'm the same. 362 00:20:41,671 --> 00:20:43,330 Well, I have good news. 363 00:20:44,027 --> 00:20:46,616 We've found an eyewitness from the night of the murder. 364 00:20:46,641 --> 00:20:47,547 Really? 365 00:20:47,860 --> 00:20:51,610 He spoke to MacLennan back in '96, but they never followed up. 366 00:20:52,077 --> 00:20:53,296 You found him? 367 00:20:53,691 --> 00:20:55,730 Janice and I searched everything. 368 00:20:55,755 --> 00:20:57,962 Thought Barney had taken it to the grave. 369 00:20:57,987 --> 00:21:00,320 And then we put a call out for him. 370 00:21:00,345 --> 00:21:03,290 Posters, flyers, we went door-to-door. 371 00:21:03,315 --> 00:21:05,551 - And no-one come forward? - How did you find him? 372 00:21:05,961 --> 00:21:07,600 We did an appeal on the podcast. 373 00:21:07,601 --> 00:21:10,001 I thought that thing would be nothing but nuisance. 374 00:21:10,885 --> 00:21:12,416 Well, the problem is... 375 00:21:13,154 --> 00:21:15,400 he saw a white man in a BMW. 376 00:21:15,401 --> 00:21:17,565 And we've got Alex Gilbey in custody, 377 00:21:17,590 --> 00:21:19,454 who obviously doesn't match that description. 378 00:21:19,455 --> 00:21:22,247 - It could have been Tom Mackie. - He was still in the Audi. 379 00:21:22,602 --> 00:21:24,355 Until it ran out of petrol. 380 00:21:24,563 --> 00:21:27,519 Could have stolen another motor to get back to the party. 381 00:21:34,941 --> 00:21:36,714 Any news on Tom Mackie? 382 00:21:36,739 --> 00:21:38,496 He's stable, but still not conscious. 383 00:21:38,521 --> 00:21:40,714 OK, I need you... 384 00:21:41,407 --> 00:21:42,712 to ask the lab 385 00:21:42,821 --> 00:21:45,564 to cross-check the fibres found in Rosie's cardigan 386 00:21:45,565 --> 00:21:50,286 with those you would find on an '80s or '90s BMW 325i. 387 00:21:50,287 --> 00:21:52,702 Also, can you get together a list 388 00:21:52,703 --> 00:21:58,220 of everyone that owned a BMW 325i in Fife in 1996? 389 00:21:59,042 --> 00:22:02,266 - How would I do that? - Call the DVLA. They'll have records. 390 00:22:02,267 --> 00:22:03,994 Uh... is that your dinner? 391 00:22:04,019 --> 00:22:07,419 Just to keep the protein up. I boil 12 at a time, so... 392 00:22:09,607 --> 00:22:11,124 Right. OK. 393 00:22:11,125 --> 00:22:13,456 New office rule. One egg a day. 394 00:22:16,752 --> 00:22:20,870 Oh, and check reports of stolen vehicles from the summer of '96. 395 00:22:21,046 --> 00:22:22,451 Yes, Sarge. 396 00:22:25,917 --> 00:22:27,637 I'm just gonna finish this one. 397 00:22:29,230 --> 00:22:30,710 We have 12 hours. 398 00:22:49,233 --> 00:22:51,713 No stolen BMWs that I could find. 399 00:23:47,849 --> 00:23:50,589 The paint on her cardigan. Was it ever analysed? 400 00:23:50,590 --> 00:23:52,750 - Nope. - Why not? 401 00:23:53,003 --> 00:23:55,269 Archie Duff was a painter and decorator. 402 00:23:55,270 --> 00:23:57,629 Rosie used to help him from time to time, so... 403 00:23:57,630 --> 00:23:59,710 - They thought it was an old stain? - Yeah. 404 00:24:00,771 --> 00:24:02,123 It wasn't. 405 00:24:03,063 --> 00:24:04,115 Hmm? 406 00:24:04,974 --> 00:24:07,287 It's not there in the photo of her and Ziggy. 407 00:24:08,150 --> 00:24:10,470 - Are you sure? - It's not there. 408 00:24:11,750 --> 00:24:14,709 So... it happened after the party. 409 00:24:14,710 --> 00:24:16,310 But before she was found. 410 00:24:19,230 --> 00:24:21,134 The second crime scene. 411 00:24:25,517 --> 00:24:27,277 Where did she go? 412 00:24:38,136 --> 00:24:39,451 Karen. 413 00:24:40,369 --> 00:24:42,175 - Karen! - What time is it? 414 00:24:42,176 --> 00:24:44,135 I don't wanna be all Queen of Wellness again, 415 00:24:44,136 --> 00:24:46,336 but you're still wearing your shoes. 416 00:24:52,376 --> 00:24:56,232 - David Soanes. - David Soanes. I love David Soanes. 417 00:24:56,257 --> 00:24:57,656 He's like a paint guy, right? 418 00:24:57,657 --> 00:25:01,457 Uh, he is the pre-eminent forensic specialist in paint, Karen. 419 00:25:03,432 --> 00:25:05,512 You know him? He's at Dundee? 420 00:25:05,537 --> 00:25:08,198 I know him, and I want him to be my grandpa, yes. 421 00:25:09,837 --> 00:25:12,437 I will go through all the proper channels as well, 422 00:25:12,462 --> 00:25:15,073 but I need his opinion on a paint sample, fast. 423 00:25:15,074 --> 00:25:17,657 - How fast? - Four hours fast. 424 00:25:18,497 --> 00:25:19,998 Bike it to me when you get in. 425 00:25:23,630 --> 00:25:25,483 You are surprisingly useful. 426 00:25:26,755 --> 00:25:28,579 Brush your hair, you look mad. 427 00:25:29,108 --> 00:25:30,791 Evidentially, what do we have? 428 00:25:30,792 --> 00:25:33,729 We have the photograph, proving that she was at the party. 429 00:25:33,730 --> 00:25:35,900 We have the semen stains on her cardigan, 430 00:25:35,901 --> 00:25:38,350 proving Alex Gilbey had sexual relations with her, 431 00:25:38,351 --> 00:25:41,823 and we have the diary and Iona's testimony, 432 00:25:41,824 --> 00:25:44,480 showing that she was having a relationship in secret. 433 00:25:44,481 --> 00:25:45,826 And what don't we have? 434 00:25:45,827 --> 00:25:48,346 We don't have a second crime scene, a murder weapon, 435 00:25:48,347 --> 00:25:50,222 or the car that allegedly picked her up. 436 00:25:50,223 --> 00:25:52,826 The fibres from her cardigan, they don't match the Audi, 437 00:25:52,827 --> 00:25:55,306 but they do match the carpet from a BMW. 438 00:25:55,307 --> 00:25:58,529 No stolen BMWs reported in the area, though. 439 00:25:58,530 --> 00:26:00,106 The DVLA have come through 440 00:26:00,107 --> 00:26:03,147 with a list of 35 similar cars in Fife at the time. 441 00:26:03,373 --> 00:26:05,866 Murray's going to talk to the owners, but that may take a while. 442 00:26:05,867 --> 00:26:09,587 - Tom Mackie still comatose? - Unfortunately, yes. 443 00:26:09,849 --> 00:26:12,911 Well, where are we, Pirie? 444 00:26:13,147 --> 00:26:14,553 Can we charge? 445 00:26:14,947 --> 00:26:17,146 - 'Hey, OK.' - I've got two minutes. 446 00:26:17,147 --> 00:26:21,255 I spoke to David. He can have a full analysis done for you by tomorrow. 447 00:26:21,380 --> 00:26:22,670 Damn it! 448 00:26:22,671 --> 00:26:25,466 'But he did have a quick look under the microscope this morning. 449 00:26:25,467 --> 00:26:26,906 'At first glance, ' 450 00:26:26,907 --> 00:26:28,746 he thinks it's a fibreglass paint, 451 00:26:28,747 --> 00:26:32,506 the kind of thing used on boats, really hard-wearing and waterproof. 452 00:26:32,507 --> 00:26:33,952 Boats? 453 00:26:34,147 --> 00:26:36,290 All right. Thanks, Riv. I've got to go. 454 00:26:42,267 --> 00:26:45,266 Mr Gilbey, you said the last time you saw Rosie Duff 455 00:26:45,267 --> 00:26:46,786 was her walking away from you 456 00:26:46,787 --> 00:26:48,826 outside the party on Scooniehill Lane. 457 00:26:48,827 --> 00:26:50,907 Do you know where she went after that? 458 00:26:51,250 --> 00:26:54,010 No. She said she was going back to the pub. 459 00:26:56,867 --> 00:26:58,419 She was wearing this cardigan. 460 00:26:59,507 --> 00:27:01,471 Yeah, we've been through this. 461 00:27:01,747 --> 00:27:03,133 Later... 462 00:27:04,406 --> 00:27:07,836 ...that same part of the top had a streak of paint on it. 463 00:27:08,481 --> 00:27:10,808 Do you know where she could have come into contact with wet paint? 464 00:27:11,414 --> 00:27:12,372 No. 465 00:27:12,766 --> 00:27:14,117 You're an artist. 466 00:27:14,251 --> 00:27:16,890 Graphic designer. I use computers. 467 00:27:16,915 --> 00:27:17,867 You were studying art. 468 00:27:17,868 --> 00:27:20,747 History of art. Which is mainly essays. 469 00:27:22,027 --> 00:27:25,002 - Did Rosie come back to the house? - No, she never came to the house. 470 00:27:28,994 --> 00:27:31,033 We've had analysis done on the paint. 471 00:27:31,034 --> 00:27:32,896 And we think it might be fibreglass primer, 472 00:27:32,897 --> 00:27:35,073 the kind used on hulls of boats. 473 00:27:36,497 --> 00:27:38,953 So you knew I didn't use it for portrait-painting. 474 00:27:38,954 --> 00:27:40,094 This is a joke. 475 00:27:40,095 --> 00:27:41,839 Was there a place that you two went together? 476 00:27:41,840 --> 00:27:43,913 A boat house? A boat in the harbour? 477 00:27:43,914 --> 00:27:46,656 - Nowhere like that. - Did she ever mention a boat? 478 00:27:47,834 --> 00:27:49,874 - Did anyone she know have one? - No, never. 479 00:27:51,207 --> 00:27:52,447 This is a mess. 480 00:27:55,914 --> 00:27:58,073 Please, let me go. 481 00:27:58,074 --> 00:27:59,157 The Audi. 482 00:27:59,383 --> 00:28:01,503 It was Tom Mackie's idea to steal it. 483 00:28:01,902 --> 00:28:03,900 Had he stolen cars before? 484 00:28:04,154 --> 00:28:08,082 I heard stories that he and Ziggy did it for fun back in Kirkcaldy. 485 00:28:08,514 --> 00:28:09,954 But they always put it back. 486 00:28:10,134 --> 00:28:12,113 Did Tom steal any other cars that night? 487 00:28:12,114 --> 00:28:15,313 Not that I know of. Well, he didn't mention it to me. 488 00:28:15,314 --> 00:28:17,233 Did you know anyone that drove a BMW? 489 00:28:17,234 --> 00:28:19,354 Specifically, a 325i. 490 00:28:22,634 --> 00:28:24,956 You know I didn't do it, don't you? 491 00:28:24,957 --> 00:28:26,183 Does that jog any memories? 492 00:28:26,184 --> 00:28:28,996 You've got something. But you can't connect it to me. 493 00:28:29,368 --> 00:28:31,273 We're still investigating all possibilities. 494 00:28:31,274 --> 00:28:32,593 It's not me, it's never been me, 495 00:28:32,594 --> 00:28:34,433 and all of this has just been a waste of time. 496 00:28:34,434 --> 00:28:36,443 You've wasted our time, Alex. 497 00:28:36,914 --> 00:28:40,276 25 years of time by lying, 498 00:28:40,874 --> 00:28:43,273 and I still don't understand why for so long. 499 00:28:43,274 --> 00:28:44,423 Why?! 500 00:28:44,874 --> 00:28:47,119 Because I didn't do it. 501 00:28:47,340 --> 00:28:49,673 Because I wasn't there when she was killed 502 00:28:49,674 --> 00:28:51,998 and I knew nothing about what happened, 503 00:28:51,999 --> 00:28:54,378 so what do you want me to say to help? 504 00:28:55,057 --> 00:28:57,513 I would have been charged for murder years ago 505 00:28:57,514 --> 00:28:59,919 if I'd been honest about Rosie and me. 506 00:29:00,394 --> 00:29:02,726 I knew it, Ziggy knew it. 507 00:29:02,914 --> 00:29:04,757 Even Weird knew it, that... 508 00:29:04,758 --> 00:29:09,233 that in that scenario, being a Black man in a very white country 509 00:29:09,234 --> 00:29:11,514 would do me no favours. 510 00:29:12,514 --> 00:29:16,874 So I protected myself, and they protected me, too. 511 00:29:19,834 --> 00:29:22,314 Even when we weren't as close. 512 00:29:24,394 --> 00:29:28,013 Even when they were under such great pressure, 513 00:29:28,274 --> 00:29:30,387 they continued to protect me. 514 00:29:30,834 --> 00:29:36,210 Even if things are different now, we stick by each other. Yeah? 515 00:29:38,554 --> 00:29:40,002 We keep our promises. 516 00:29:41,354 --> 00:29:43,034 And we hold the course. 517 00:29:50,834 --> 00:29:52,539 We were young. 518 00:29:52,994 --> 00:29:54,545 We were drunk. 519 00:29:54,794 --> 00:29:57,088 We made a panicked decision. 520 00:29:57,474 --> 00:30:00,154 But who's to say that even if we told the truth... 521 00:30:01,994 --> 00:30:03,851 ...that it would make things better? 522 00:30:04,434 --> 00:30:08,015 We might be... serving life... 523 00:30:09,114 --> 00:30:11,874 for a murder we didn't commit. 524 00:30:15,812 --> 00:30:17,634 What justice... 525 00:30:18,984 --> 00:30:20,486 ...would that have been? 526 00:30:27,166 --> 00:30:29,274 Thank you for your co-operation, Mr Gilbey. 527 00:30:30,371 --> 00:30:33,371 I hope this new iteration of your story is the final, truthful one. 528 00:30:36,037 --> 00:30:37,349 It is. 529 00:30:39,382 --> 00:30:40,790 We're gonna release you. 530 00:30:41,855 --> 00:30:44,451 You can go home to your wife and to your baby. 531 00:30:47,474 --> 00:30:48,594 Thank you. 532 00:30:50,914 --> 00:30:52,394 Thank you. 533 00:31:23,074 --> 00:31:24,514 We still have options. 534 00:31:37,554 --> 00:31:38,914 It wasn't them. 535 00:31:41,404 --> 00:31:42,858 There's someone else. 536 00:31:43,194 --> 00:31:45,514 There's always been someone else. 537 00:31:50,234 --> 00:31:52,408 For a moment yesterday... 538 00:31:54,329 --> 00:31:56,348 ...I really thought we had him. 539 00:31:56,714 --> 00:31:58,380 I imagined the moment. 540 00:31:59,794 --> 00:32:01,634 Being able to tell her brothers... 541 00:32:04,155 --> 00:32:05,714 ...her daughter. 542 00:32:14,314 --> 00:32:16,914 She was meant to come in for a DNA test today, wasn't she? 543 00:32:17,914 --> 00:32:20,514 Have you got a number I can get her on? She didn't show. 544 00:33:17,518 --> 00:33:19,785 - My father's. - Jesus Christ! 545 00:33:20,954 --> 00:33:23,532 Sorry. I did knock. 546 00:33:23,533 --> 00:33:26,634 I just, erm... I thought you might be out here somewhere. 547 00:33:26,969 --> 00:33:30,769 - You need to store these securely. - Yeah, I was just locking it up. 548 00:33:40,514 --> 00:33:41,920 Do you want to come in? 549 00:33:42,127 --> 00:33:43,228 Yeah. 550 00:33:43,834 --> 00:33:45,794 So you made an arrest? 551 00:33:46,834 --> 00:33:49,046 Twitter. Bel Richmond. 552 00:33:49,470 --> 00:33:53,114 Ah. So you've been listening? 553 00:33:55,754 --> 00:33:57,576 It's become hard to ignore. 554 00:33:58,554 --> 00:34:00,834 You weren't going to tell me, then? 555 00:34:01,514 --> 00:34:03,674 That's why I'm here, actually. 556 00:34:05,674 --> 00:34:07,914 Surely I should know before Twitter does. 557 00:34:11,482 --> 00:34:12,681 Yeah. 558 00:34:13,346 --> 00:34:14,514 You should. 559 00:34:15,794 --> 00:34:18,037 - Sorry. - Who is it? 560 00:34:19,229 --> 00:34:22,069 Who have you arrested? Is it one of the students? 561 00:34:24,674 --> 00:34:27,394 I don't want to keep anything from you, Grace. 562 00:34:29,274 --> 00:34:31,543 We arrested a man called Alex Gilbey. 563 00:34:31,724 --> 00:34:34,793 And after questioning him for the last two days, 564 00:34:34,794 --> 00:34:37,234 we've decided to release him without charge. 565 00:34:38,197 --> 00:34:39,354 You let him go? 566 00:34:39,378 --> 00:34:41,170 I'm sorry I can't bring you more hopeful news. 567 00:34:41,194 --> 00:34:43,220 You must have had a good reason to arrest him. 568 00:34:43,221 --> 00:34:44,722 - We did. - So what happened? 569 00:34:44,723 --> 00:34:47,518 I'm sorry, I can't discuss the details with you. Not yet. 570 00:34:49,834 --> 00:34:51,089 Right. 571 00:34:54,187 --> 00:34:58,754 Did you... change your mind about the DNA test? 572 00:34:58,965 --> 00:35:01,073 My DC said you missed an appointment. 573 00:35:01,074 --> 00:35:03,794 We can send someone up here if you want? 574 00:35:06,737 --> 00:35:09,495 My... father... 575 00:35:11,495 --> 00:35:13,302 My adoptive father... 576 00:35:14,074 --> 00:35:15,396 he doesn't know. 577 00:35:16,154 --> 00:35:19,634 About any of this. That I traced my mother. 578 00:35:20,969 --> 00:35:23,059 He's in a rest home, he's not well. 579 00:35:23,634 --> 00:35:24,954 I just... 580 00:35:25,954 --> 00:35:27,211 It doesn't feel right. 581 00:35:28,355 --> 00:35:31,154 Finding out who my real dad is without telling him first. 582 00:35:31,754 --> 00:35:32,594 Yeah. 583 00:35:34,076 --> 00:35:35,089 I get that. 584 00:35:35,994 --> 00:35:37,634 Take all the time you need. 585 00:35:39,196 --> 00:35:42,145 Grace, I just want to say... 586 00:35:43,306 --> 00:35:45,417 this could really help us. 587 00:35:45,514 --> 00:35:48,434 It's an avenue we've never been able to explore until now. 588 00:35:50,629 --> 00:35:53,043 Feels like the wrong thing to focus on, to me. 589 00:35:57,634 --> 00:35:58,547 OK. 590 00:36:00,678 --> 00:36:03,742 Think about it, eh? Will you? 591 00:36:07,714 --> 00:36:08,908 Is that all? 592 00:36:12,914 --> 00:36:13,887 Yeah. 593 00:36:17,434 --> 00:36:18,358 Thanks. 594 00:36:21,351 --> 00:36:23,759 That's great, cheers. Bye-bye now. 595 00:36:27,122 --> 00:36:30,788 How many BMW owners have you spoken to now? 596 00:36:30,789 --> 00:36:34,473 18. Well, actually 20, but two of them were dead. 597 00:36:34,474 --> 00:36:36,853 Anything of interest? From the living ones. 598 00:36:36,854 --> 00:36:39,788 Not one of them remembered their car going missing during that period. 599 00:36:39,789 --> 00:36:41,499 No-one noticed anything suspicious. 600 00:36:41,500 --> 00:36:44,112 - Most of them weren't in St Andrews. - Perfect. 601 00:36:45,514 --> 00:36:47,473 How'd it go with the daughter? 602 00:36:47,474 --> 00:36:50,354 She's changed her mind. About tracing her father. 603 00:36:51,340 --> 00:36:54,340 Really? You'd think she'd want to help with the investigation. 604 00:36:54,434 --> 00:36:55,554 Yeah. 605 00:37:08,560 --> 00:37:10,160 It is so good to have you home. 606 00:37:25,394 --> 00:37:27,354 - Just though here. - Right, thanks. 607 00:37:28,440 --> 00:37:33,074 Well, this is so different from the old St Andrews police station. 608 00:37:33,352 --> 00:37:34,632 It's not cosy, is it? 609 00:37:34,657 --> 00:37:36,553 Eh... it's less claustrophobic. 610 00:37:36,554 --> 00:37:39,977 Everyone was always on top of each other down at that old place. 611 00:37:40,283 --> 00:37:43,274 Thank you for coming. Please. 612 00:37:46,074 --> 00:37:48,950 I just want to talk about the original investigation. 613 00:37:49,154 --> 00:37:52,634 How it was run, on the inside. MacLennan? 614 00:37:53,346 --> 00:37:55,626 Aye, he was a great man, Karen. 615 00:37:55,627 --> 00:37:58,084 Everyone loved him. I adored him. 616 00:37:59,821 --> 00:38:01,873 Do you think he was a good detective? 617 00:38:01,874 --> 00:38:05,986 He was all I knew. Don't have much to compare it to. 618 00:38:08,634 --> 00:38:11,505 There was an eyewitness that contacted him. 619 00:38:11,506 --> 00:38:12,250 Yes. 620 00:38:12,274 --> 00:38:14,593 Can you just tell me how that happened? 621 00:38:14,594 --> 00:38:16,273 When you first heard of it? 622 00:38:16,274 --> 00:38:18,874 So, he mentioned it to me that last day. 623 00:38:20,554 --> 00:38:22,486 The day he died. 624 00:38:22,946 --> 00:38:24,758 We were all in the pub that night, 625 00:38:24,783 --> 00:38:26,553 and he asked me if I was working the next morning. 626 00:38:26,554 --> 00:38:28,461 I said, "Aye," and he said he wanted me 627 00:38:28,486 --> 00:38:30,121 to come with him to interview a witness. 628 00:38:31,329 --> 00:38:33,889 And he didn't write anything about it down? 629 00:38:34,382 --> 00:38:35,433 No... 630 00:38:35,434 --> 00:38:38,194 and he never told anyone about it except me. 631 00:38:39,474 --> 00:38:40,953 Why do you think he did that? 632 00:38:40,954 --> 00:38:43,914 Oh, I don't know. Erm... 633 00:38:44,026 --> 00:38:46,833 He was old school. Didnae love paperwork. 634 00:38:46,834 --> 00:38:51,193 And then you and Lawson tried to track him down and couldn't? 635 00:38:51,194 --> 00:38:53,988 Well, Jimmy was trying to when I was moved off the case. 636 00:38:53,989 --> 00:38:56,976 I tried to check in afterwards, see how it was going, but... 637 00:38:56,977 --> 00:38:59,914 he was a bit cagey. Understandably, I suppose. 638 00:39:01,074 --> 00:39:04,154 Because of... me and Colin. 639 00:39:06,994 --> 00:39:09,714 Is that why you were taken off the investigation? 640 00:39:11,914 --> 00:39:16,816 I wonder if Barney had been alive, he might have let it slide, but... 641 00:39:17,062 --> 00:39:19,314 Lawson took over and didn't approve? 642 00:39:20,000 --> 00:39:22,807 I think he had some personal issues with us. 643 00:39:24,552 --> 00:39:26,034 What do you mean? 644 00:39:26,958 --> 00:39:30,238 Jimmy had an eye for me, I suppose, 645 00:39:30,394 --> 00:39:34,073 and I didnae want to bring that up at work, so I went to go see him. 646 00:39:34,074 --> 00:39:35,526 At his house? 647 00:39:35,956 --> 00:39:40,586 You couldn't really call it a house! He'd bought this wreck. 648 00:39:40,966 --> 00:39:43,113 Jimmy was so desperate to move up in the world, 649 00:39:43,114 --> 00:39:45,913 he'd got this big old ruin for next to nothing. 650 00:39:45,914 --> 00:39:46,931 He was doing it up himself, 651 00:39:46,932 --> 00:39:50,251 so he was living in this tin-can caravan in the garden. 652 00:39:51,592 --> 00:39:54,353 - Janice. - Sorry to come so late, I just... 653 00:39:54,354 --> 00:39:56,034 Nae bother. 654 00:39:57,354 --> 00:39:58,914 I just wanted to... 655 00:40:00,834 --> 00:40:02,332 Colin and I... 656 00:40:02,794 --> 00:40:04,504 we're old friends. 657 00:40:04,874 --> 00:40:06,925 I just wanted to make sure you knew that. 658 00:40:06,926 --> 00:40:08,594 Come on, you're more than that. 659 00:40:09,754 --> 00:40:10,638 No. 660 00:40:11,234 --> 00:40:12,726 You don't have to lie to me, Jan. 661 00:40:13,034 --> 00:40:14,914 You're seeing each other. Right? 662 00:40:16,239 --> 00:40:17,599 Not really. 663 00:40:19,034 --> 00:40:21,009 It won't get in the way of work. 664 00:40:21,010 --> 00:40:23,429 - I've known him for a long time... - Of course, you... 665 00:40:24,194 --> 00:40:26,554 You go ahead. But, er... 666 00:40:27,874 --> 00:40:29,634 ...I'm taking you off the case. 667 00:40:32,034 --> 00:40:33,068 No. 668 00:40:33,394 --> 00:40:34,673 No, don't do that. 669 00:40:34,674 --> 00:40:36,007 I'm sorry, I've just done it. 670 00:40:36,008 --> 00:40:37,543 No, Jimmy, come on. 671 00:40:38,114 --> 00:40:39,494 I found her. 672 00:40:39,799 --> 00:40:41,526 I was the one that found her. 673 00:40:41,639 --> 00:40:44,858 And now... you're sleeping with her brother. 674 00:40:46,555 --> 00:40:49,314 That was your decision. You had other options. 675 00:40:51,013 --> 00:40:52,809 Jimmy, I'm sorry if I... 676 00:40:53,829 --> 00:40:55,456 You and me, I didn't... 677 00:40:55,909 --> 00:40:58,377 - I don't... - It's all right. You can say it. 678 00:40:59,197 --> 00:41:02,914 - You don't like me like that. - Don't take me off the case, Jimmy. 679 00:41:03,759 --> 00:41:06,719 I was making a difference to that case. 680 00:41:07,204 --> 00:41:08,549 And I blew it. 681 00:41:09,474 --> 00:41:12,474 Rosie had me and Barney on her side... 682 00:41:13,557 --> 00:41:17,037 ...and then she lost the both of us at the same time. 683 00:41:17,154 --> 00:41:19,393 You don't think Lawson was as effective? 684 00:41:19,394 --> 00:41:22,473 He got another murder case through soon after, 685 00:41:22,474 --> 00:41:25,307 solved it really quickly. Impressively. 686 00:41:25,308 --> 00:41:28,713 Then he really started moving up through the ranks. 687 00:41:28,714 --> 00:41:31,602 And the Duff case just became less of a priority? 688 00:41:31,603 --> 00:41:33,937 Once the press interest had waned... 689 00:41:35,874 --> 00:41:37,977 And you left the force soon after. 690 00:41:38,754 --> 00:41:39,725 Why? 691 00:41:40,432 --> 00:41:42,953 I never knew how good I was, Karen. 692 00:41:42,954 --> 00:41:46,074 I don't think anyone would have thought to tell me. 693 00:41:46,314 --> 00:41:48,874 Think I'm only starting to realise that now. 694 00:41:50,394 --> 00:41:53,194 Dinnae let that happen to you, now, d'you hear me? 695 00:41:58,274 --> 00:41:59,898 Keep going, Karen. 696 00:42:00,760 --> 00:42:03,151 Colin and Brian don't trust the police, but... 697 00:42:04,557 --> 00:42:06,011 ...that's not your fault. 698 00:42:06,714 --> 00:42:07,954 It was ours. 699 00:42:18,154 --> 00:42:19,754 Shh... 700 00:42:35,032 --> 00:42:37,876 I know what you would like. 701 00:42:38,408 --> 00:42:39,834 Come on. 702 00:43:10,674 --> 00:43:11,993 Hi there. 703 00:43:11,994 --> 00:43:14,833 Hi, I'm sorry to call so late. I'm DC Murray. 704 00:43:14,834 --> 00:43:18,074 Am I right in saying you used to own a BMW 325i? 705 00:43:20,274 --> 00:43:21,673 It's a lovely car, yeah. 706 00:43:21,674 --> 00:43:24,234 And German engineering's fantastic, yeah. 707 00:44:09,247 --> 00:44:10,695 Is everything all right? 708 00:44:12,684 --> 00:44:13,873 Hello. 709 00:44:13,874 --> 00:44:15,423 - Don't move! - Whoa! 710 00:44:16,028 --> 00:44:17,603 I said don't move! 711 00:44:22,874 --> 00:44:25,193 - J-J-Just lower the gun. - Stay there! 712 00:44:25,194 --> 00:44:26,510 All right, all right. 713 00:44:26,754 --> 00:44:28,354 Please... 714 00:44:29,436 --> 00:44:31,596 ...please, whatever you want, just lower the gun. 715 00:44:31,697 --> 00:44:34,334 I want to know what happened to Rosie Duff. 716 00:44:41,334 --> 00:44:43,273 - I don't know what happened to her... - Liar! 717 00:44:43,274 --> 00:44:44,314 I honestly don't. 718 00:44:45,434 --> 00:44:47,233 - I wish I did. - You killed her. 719 00:44:47,234 --> 00:44:48,354 No. 720 00:44:49,474 --> 00:44:51,154 Who are you? 721 00:44:53,166 --> 00:44:55,286 You killed my mother. 722 00:44:57,328 --> 00:44:58,714 She was your mother? 723 00:45:02,292 --> 00:45:03,652 I'm... 724 00:45:03,754 --> 00:45:06,422 I'm so, so sorry, but I didn't kill your mother... 725 00:45:06,447 --> 00:45:07,826 - I said stay there! - All right! All right! 726 00:45:07,827 --> 00:45:09,794 I am not afraid of you. 727 00:45:14,514 --> 00:45:16,554 Tell me why you killed her. 728 00:45:18,107 --> 00:45:19,571 I loved her. 729 00:45:20,042 --> 00:45:22,234 Tell me or I will shoot. 730 00:45:23,138 --> 00:45:27,658 I didn't! I didn't kill her. I knew her, but I didn't kill her. 731 00:45:27,994 --> 00:45:29,474 You knew her! 732 00:45:32,634 --> 00:45:34,073 But I didn't kill her. 733 00:45:34,074 --> 00:45:37,594 I can tell you about her, but not like this, please. 734 00:45:59,234 --> 00:46:00,794 I never knew about you. 735 00:46:10,468 --> 00:46:12,308 There was so much I didn't know. 736 00:46:19,861 --> 00:46:21,741 You really do look like her. 737 00:46:34,762 --> 00:46:36,522 I said, "Don't!" 738 00:47:25,794 --> 00:47:28,736 'We've got to remember that this was before 739 00:47:28,760 --> 00:47:30,947 the centralisation 'of the SPS. 740 00:47:30,972 --> 00:47:33,390 St Andrews Police was a small team. 741 00:47:33,474 --> 00:47:36,233 'Perhaps they just weren't equipped for it. 742 00:47:36,234 --> 00:47:38,499 'But the singularity of the case 743 00:47:38,565 --> 00:47:41,073 'and the shockwaves that it sent through the town 744 00:47:41,074 --> 00:47:45,793 'make it even stranger that interest seemed to fade so quickly. 745 00:47:45,794 --> 00:47:48,879 'Why didn't it continue to be a priority? 746 00:47:48,880 --> 00:47:54,151 'Why, once MacLennan was dead, did Rosie seemingly get forgotten?' 747 00:48:02,956 --> 00:48:05,930 You're walking like you're leaving a burning building. 748 00:48:15,209 --> 00:48:19,274 There's something not right at the heart of all this. 749 00:48:24,954 --> 00:48:28,595 Lawson said he did everything he could to find the eyewitness, 750 00:48:28,620 --> 00:48:31,766 yet we do one callout and we find him straight away. 751 00:48:32,213 --> 00:48:34,473 And then there's missing evidence in the warehouse. 752 00:48:34,474 --> 00:48:36,473 Why has no-one picked up on that before? 753 00:48:36,474 --> 00:48:40,154 And Bel was right. The investigation should have been reviewed. 754 00:48:40,383 --> 00:48:42,783 If Lawson really cared about the case, 755 00:48:43,034 --> 00:48:44,873 why didn't he reopen it until now? 756 00:48:44,874 --> 00:48:47,388 Is he just a really bad cop in a really nice suit? 757 00:48:47,626 --> 00:48:48,706 Or... 758 00:48:50,194 --> 00:48:51,914 ...he's covering for someone. 759 00:48:54,194 --> 00:48:57,594 Well, Grandpa Paint came through. 760 00:49:04,373 --> 00:49:06,293 - Marine primer? - He says you're lucky 761 00:49:06,434 --> 00:49:08,721 because that particular paint is actually quite rare. 762 00:49:08,722 --> 00:49:13,033 Chroma Paints. Anti-corrosive. Instant water-proofing. 763 00:49:13,034 --> 00:49:15,446 That company folded in the noughties or something. 764 00:49:15,447 --> 00:49:19,154 It's found on fibreglass boat hulls, barges, motorhomes and... 765 00:49:21,634 --> 00:49:22,908 ...caravans. 766 00:49:27,776 --> 00:49:29,408 I'm DC Murray. 767 00:49:29,914 --> 00:49:32,515 I know, I know, I'm sorry. Did I get you out of bed? 768 00:49:32,616 --> 00:49:35,359 Did you have a husband or a boyfriend who borrowed it? 769 00:49:35,788 --> 00:49:38,916 Did you used to own a BMW 325i? 770 00:49:41,317 --> 00:49:43,634 You did? Can you tell me more about that? 771 00:49:44,994 --> 00:49:46,633 Just because Lawson has a caravan... 772 00:49:46,634 --> 00:49:49,513 But it was there, right? In St Andrews. 773 00:49:49,514 --> 00:49:51,873 And you're looking for a second crime scene. 774 00:49:51,874 --> 00:49:53,753 Which you think might be a caravan. 775 00:49:53,754 --> 00:49:56,256 But how do I investigate it? I can't question him. 776 00:49:56,474 --> 00:49:58,727 He's my boss. He's my boss's boss. 777 00:50:01,155 --> 00:50:02,656 I have to find it. 778 00:50:03,474 --> 00:50:05,234 To see if the paint even matches. 779 00:50:05,815 --> 00:50:08,033 If you had a caravan, where would you keep it? 780 00:50:08,034 --> 00:50:10,875 In my driveway? I don't know. 781 00:50:10,994 --> 00:50:12,473 Where does he live? 782 00:50:12,474 --> 00:50:14,674 Some swanky townhouse in Edinburgh. 783 00:50:15,039 --> 00:50:18,834 Probably not caravan territory. Plus he might not have it any more. 784 00:50:22,674 --> 00:50:24,364 Maybe you just need to sleep on it. 785 00:50:25,432 --> 00:50:27,272 You have to look after yourself. 786 00:50:28,290 --> 00:50:30,274 That's what he said to me today. 787 00:50:38,234 --> 00:50:39,509 Loch Leven. 788 00:50:43,314 --> 00:50:45,274 He fishes in Loch Leven. 789 00:50:46,834 --> 00:50:48,881 He has a place up there. 790 00:50:50,041 --> 00:50:52,589 There's loads of pictures of him on holiday there. 791 00:50:52,914 --> 00:50:55,714 That's where he'd have it, isn't it? If he still has it. 792 00:50:59,963 --> 00:51:03,513 Are you just gonna search the screen for something caravan-shaped? 793 00:51:03,514 --> 00:51:04,953 Do you have a better idea? 794 00:51:08,834 --> 00:51:09,953 Mint. 795 00:51:09,954 --> 00:51:12,153 Sarge, I just had the weirdest thing. 796 00:51:12,154 --> 00:51:13,993 I couldn't get hold of this old lady... 797 00:51:13,994 --> 00:51:16,344 Not now, Mint, I'm onto something. 798 00:51:16,369 --> 00:51:18,172 'No, no, it's worth hearing, I think.' 799 00:51:18,255 --> 00:51:20,867 - I don't know, but... - 'Fine, well, go on, then.' 800 00:51:21,102 --> 00:51:22,528 I couldn't track her down, 801 00:51:22,553 --> 00:51:24,988 but it was because she'd been moved into a care home 802 00:51:25,013 --> 00:51:26,427 because she couldn't get up the stairs... 803 00:51:26,428 --> 00:51:27,362 Faster, Mint. 804 00:51:27,363 --> 00:51:31,959 OK, OK, yeah. Um... well, she had one of these cars up until '96, 805 00:51:31,960 --> 00:51:33,921 'and she lived in St Andrews at the time, 806 00:51:33,922 --> 00:51:37,749 'and she was telling me that her son was a copper.' 807 00:51:42,011 --> 00:51:43,966 Well, you'll never guess who her son is. 808 00:51:50,184 --> 00:51:51,342 James Lawson. 809 00:51:52,573 --> 00:51:54,091 How did you know that? 810 00:51:56,219 --> 00:51:59,705 I need you to pick me up early tomorrow morning, Mint. Early-early. 811 00:51:59,706 --> 00:52:00,912 Where are we going? 812 00:52:02,121 --> 00:52:03,742 Loch Leven. 813 00:52:06,588 --> 00:52:09,688 We can't do this. We're just gonna go up there and have a look around. 814 00:52:09,689 --> 00:52:12,538 - We're going to lose our jobs. - If we don't find anything, we drop it. 815 00:52:12,539 --> 00:52:15,596 - I can't lose my job, Sarge. - Just get in the car and hear me out. 816 00:52:15,597 --> 00:52:17,709 I'm not good at anything else! 817 00:52:20,858 --> 00:52:22,420 He's our Chief Super. 818 00:52:23,422 --> 00:52:26,548 He knew her. He was drinking in that pub, he was there that night. 819 00:52:26,549 --> 00:52:27,658 So was half the town. 820 00:52:27,659 --> 00:52:30,079 The paint on her hood, it's used on caravans. 821 00:52:30,080 --> 00:52:32,240 - He was living in a caravan. - That he probably no longer has. 822 00:52:32,241 --> 00:52:34,002 The car, Mint. He lied about the eyewitness. 823 00:52:34,003 --> 00:52:35,683 - We don't have enough proof... - YET. 824 00:52:36,004 --> 00:52:37,363 Not enough yet. 825 00:52:37,364 --> 00:52:40,266 Look, if you're not gonna drive us, then give me the keys, Jason. 826 00:53:01,284 --> 00:53:02,505 Alex? 827 00:53:08,084 --> 00:53:12,044 'Hiya, you've reached Alex. Please leave a message.' 828 00:53:35,964 --> 00:53:37,427 DS Parhatka. 829 00:53:37,871 --> 00:53:39,844 Whoa, whoa, whoa, slow down. 830 00:53:41,118 --> 00:53:43,071 OK. Right. 831 00:53:45,428 --> 00:53:46,924 Is the car there? 832 00:53:48,534 --> 00:53:49,536 No? 833 00:53:52,044 --> 00:53:53,644 All right, what's the plate? 834 00:53:53,723 --> 00:53:57,607 'Sierra, Lima, One, Seven, Juliet, Foxtrot, Victor. 835 00:53:57,608 --> 00:54:00,004 'A silver Land Rover Discovery.' 836 00:54:15,911 --> 00:54:18,314 See. It'll take us forever to search it on foot. 837 00:54:21,059 --> 00:54:24,906 Hey! Hey! Police! 838 00:54:27,354 --> 00:54:30,706 - We need your help! - He's not gonna help us. 839 00:54:34,524 --> 00:54:35,818 OK, yes! 840 00:54:38,031 --> 00:54:39,231 Sarge! 841 00:54:44,291 --> 00:54:48,703 Hi! I'm DS Pirie. This is DC Murray. 842 00:54:48,805 --> 00:54:51,341 I don't suppose you could give us a lift? 843 00:54:53,297 --> 00:54:57,110 We're looking for an old caravan used for fishing. 844 00:54:57,629 --> 00:54:59,921 Well, there's a couple of those around. 845 00:55:21,445 --> 00:55:23,965 There's one that's been here for years. 846 00:55:24,364 --> 00:55:25,724 That sounds right. 847 00:55:25,954 --> 00:55:27,628 Can you take us there? 848 00:55:45,939 --> 00:55:48,461 - Is that it? - This is your stop. 849 00:55:52,164 --> 00:55:54,444 Thank you. Thank you so much. 850 00:56:08,764 --> 00:56:10,084 Call an ambulance. 851 00:56:25,044 --> 00:56:27,523 If we're looking for primer, how are we even gonna find it? 852 00:56:27,524 --> 00:56:29,644 It'll be under the... 853 00:56:29,964 --> 00:56:31,043 You're not gonna... 854 00:56:31,044 --> 00:56:33,363 You can't scrape the paint off. We don't know if it's his. 855 00:56:33,364 --> 00:56:35,924 How are we gonna know if it's his if we don't scrape the paint off? 856 00:56:45,284 --> 00:56:46,723 We should call forensics. 857 00:56:46,724 --> 00:56:51,024 We can't, Mint. We have to do this on our own. 858 00:56:56,781 --> 00:56:58,661 Well, I guess we have to jimmy a window. 859 00:57:01,084 --> 00:57:02,199 Really? 860 00:57:25,244 --> 00:57:26,644 OK... 861 00:57:27,804 --> 00:57:30,699 - Lift me up. - You... You want to do it? 862 00:57:32,503 --> 00:57:34,343 Do you think I'm lifting you? 863 00:57:35,844 --> 00:57:37,004 Yeah. 864 00:57:53,204 --> 00:57:54,882 Can you see anything? 865 00:58:04,324 --> 00:58:05,564 It's wallpaper. 866 00:58:08,495 --> 00:58:10,375 Would you have primer under wallpaper? 867 00:58:15,715 --> 00:58:18,715 OK... OK. 868 00:58:34,204 --> 00:58:35,644 What are you doing? 869 00:59:23,724 --> 00:59:25,995 You nasty little worm. 870 00:59:28,619 --> 00:59:33,257 He was waterproofing the door, and it looks like it was over a repair. 871 00:59:34,719 --> 00:59:38,233 Normally, you could avoid wet paint like that... 872 00:59:40,244 --> 00:59:43,711 ...but not when you're carrying... 873 00:59:47,461 --> 00:59:48,840 ...a body. 874 00:59:55,360 --> 00:59:56,800 He killed her, Mint. 875 01:00:00,599 --> 01:00:02,579 Lawson killed Rosie. 876 01:00:03,778 --> 01:00:06,044 - Any sign of the baby? - Nowhere. 877 01:00:07,138 --> 01:00:10,258 - Is he alive? - Yes, he's lost lots of blood. 878 01:00:13,404 --> 01:00:16,807 Hey. Alex, Alex... Who did this to you? 879 01:00:31,835 --> 01:00:32,851 Hello? 880 01:00:32,852 --> 01:00:34,145 'Where the hell have you been?' 881 01:00:34,146 --> 01:00:36,977 - Whoa! - 'I've been trying to call you!' 882 01:00:36,978 --> 01:00:39,642 I've been in Loch Leven. There's no signal. 883 01:00:39,643 --> 01:00:42,033 'Rosie's daughter has taken Alex's kid.' 884 01:00:42,878 --> 01:00:44,819 - What?! - 'Where does she live?' 885 01:00:45,440 --> 01:00:47,364 Jesus, er... she's... 886 01:00:47,450 --> 01:00:48,855 Her name's Grace Galloway. 887 01:00:48,880 --> 01:00:50,919 She lives on a big farm up in the middle of nowhere. 888 01:00:50,920 --> 01:00:52,354 'Send me the address and meet me there.' 889 01:00:52,355 --> 01:00:54,129 OK. Send him the address. 890 01:00:54,130 --> 01:00:56,037 'If you get there first, be careful, OK? 891 01:00:56,038 --> 01:00:59,080 'I don't know what she's gonna do to you or the child.' 892 01:01:14,267 --> 01:01:15,762 Oh, God. 893 01:01:17,571 --> 01:01:19,095 Oh, God. 894 01:01:24,483 --> 01:01:26,654 - Maybe we should wait here, Sarge. - Nope. 895 01:01:26,655 --> 01:01:29,052 Shouldn't we wait for a negotiator or something? 896 01:01:29,053 --> 01:01:32,393 - We don't need a negotiator. - It's a hostage situation, Sarge. 897 01:01:35,125 --> 01:01:36,645 You're nuts, you know that? 898 01:01:36,670 --> 01:01:38,167 That's what you were thinking, wasn't it, 899 01:01:38,168 --> 01:01:39,862 when I said we had to investigate Lawson? 900 01:01:40,205 --> 01:01:41,755 Look how that turned out. 901 01:01:47,122 --> 01:01:48,961 OK. You're not going in there, though. 902 01:01:48,962 --> 01:01:50,953 - I want you to do one thing. - What is it? 903 01:01:50,978 --> 01:01:53,537 Make sure news of this gets back to Lawson. 904 01:01:53,538 --> 01:01:54,777 What? 905 01:01:54,778 --> 01:01:56,017 Shh. Shh. 906 01:01:56,018 --> 01:01:58,258 What do you mean? Sarge! 907 01:02:02,098 --> 01:02:03,778 - Sarge. - Shh! 908 01:02:23,139 --> 01:02:24,899 Don't move. 909 01:02:28,698 --> 01:02:30,298 Close the door. 910 01:02:45,858 --> 01:02:47,498 Where's the baby, Grace? 911 01:02:49,727 --> 01:02:53,479 Stay there... or I will shoot you. 912 01:02:54,019 --> 01:02:57,418 - 'Reception, how can I help you?' - Er... I need DCS Lawson's office. 913 01:02:58,820 --> 01:03:00,457 Sir, it's DC Murray. 914 01:03:00,458 --> 01:03:02,377 I know it's kinda strange to call you directly, 915 01:03:02,378 --> 01:03:04,897 but, erm... given your knowledge of the case... 916 01:03:04,898 --> 01:03:06,617 'Is everything all right, Murray?' 917 01:03:06,618 --> 01:03:09,298 No, it's DS Pirie. 918 01:03:10,338 --> 01:03:12,721 - She's in danger, Sir. - 'Where are you?' 919 01:03:12,722 --> 01:03:15,097 I need to know the baby's safe, Grace. 920 01:03:15,098 --> 01:03:17,937 - What for? - Her parents will be torn up. 921 01:03:17,938 --> 01:03:21,003 I'm torn up. Why does no-one care about that? 922 01:03:21,004 --> 01:03:22,917 I do. I want to help you. 923 01:03:22,918 --> 01:03:24,778 You can't help me. 924 01:03:26,538 --> 01:03:28,629 I know I'm going down for this. 925 01:03:29,771 --> 01:03:31,972 It's really just a matter of who I bring down with me. 926 01:03:31,997 --> 01:03:33,215 I can tell you what you want to know. 927 01:03:33,216 --> 01:03:35,190 - You don't know anything. - That's where you're wrong. 928 01:03:35,895 --> 01:03:39,516 The police did fail your mother in the past. But I haven't. 929 01:03:39,517 --> 01:03:40,729 I won't. 930 01:03:42,555 --> 01:03:46,637 Show me where the baby is, and I'll tell you who I think killed her. 931 01:03:49,596 --> 01:03:51,858 I can give you the answers you want. 932 01:03:53,114 --> 01:03:56,988 You think the three boys did it. The ones who found her. 933 01:03:57,030 --> 01:03:58,528 That's what you've been doing, isn't it? 934 01:03:58,529 --> 01:04:00,335 - Chasing them down, on her behalf. - No. 935 01:04:00,360 --> 01:04:03,252 - She wouldn't want that. - You don't know what she'd want. 936 01:04:03,253 --> 01:04:05,936 She was seeing one of them. Alex. 937 01:04:08,517 --> 01:04:10,019 The one you let go? 938 01:04:10,020 --> 01:04:13,637 She liked him. Really liked him, I think. 939 01:04:14,796 --> 01:04:17,268 That's his baby you've got somewhere in this house. 940 01:04:17,404 --> 01:04:19,046 What would she think of that? 941 01:04:24,408 --> 01:04:27,561 If it wasn't them, then... then who was it? 942 01:04:28,740 --> 01:04:32,347 Show me the child, and I'll tell you. 943 01:04:34,802 --> 01:04:36,056 Tell me... 944 01:04:37,955 --> 01:04:39,977 ...or I will shoot you. 945 01:04:41,082 --> 01:04:44,071 Shoot me, and you will never know. 946 01:04:48,675 --> 01:04:50,075 Show me. 947 01:04:54,655 --> 01:04:56,415 Walk through the hallway. 948 01:05:15,591 --> 01:05:16,797 Stop. 949 01:05:17,894 --> 01:05:19,718 Tell them to stay back. 950 01:05:19,719 --> 01:05:22,447 - Call them! - OK, OK... 951 01:05:29,978 --> 01:05:31,465 'Sarge, are you OK?' 952 01:05:31,490 --> 01:05:33,474 You and the other officers need to stay back. 953 01:05:33,631 --> 01:05:35,215 - 'Sarge?' - It's all right. 954 01:05:35,239 --> 01:05:36,773 I've got it under control. Just... 955 01:05:37,473 --> 01:05:39,020 keep your distance. 956 01:05:39,197 --> 01:05:40,717 'Understood.' 957 01:05:41,991 --> 01:05:43,868 It's all right. They're not coming in. 958 01:05:44,768 --> 01:05:46,140 It's just me and you. 959 01:05:48,659 --> 01:05:50,339 It's the door on the right. 960 01:06:09,218 --> 01:06:10,378 It's your turn. 961 01:06:13,082 --> 01:06:15,426 I'm gonna need to move me and the baby 962 01:06:15,427 --> 01:06:17,560 over to the window, if you'll let me? 963 01:06:18,487 --> 01:06:19,526 Why? 964 01:06:19,550 --> 01:06:21,852 To let my fellow officers know we're all right. 965 01:06:21,956 --> 01:06:25,156 And that way, they won't burst in on us until we're finished. 966 01:06:59,440 --> 01:07:00,965 All right. 967 01:07:01,619 --> 01:07:04,197 Now tell me. We made a deal. 968 01:07:08,021 --> 01:07:11,876 There are a few new things we know about your mother's last movements. 969 01:07:12,216 --> 01:07:13,835 We know she went to a party. 970 01:07:14,517 --> 01:07:16,211 And then we know she left, 971 01:07:16,212 --> 01:07:18,925 to walk back to the pub where she was meeting her brothers. 972 01:07:20,469 --> 01:07:23,601 But on the way, it started to rain. 973 01:07:24,314 --> 01:07:26,708 She was offered a lift from someone she knew. 974 01:07:26,997 --> 01:07:28,479 Someone she trusted. 975 01:07:31,169 --> 01:07:33,201 I believe it was a police officer. 976 01:07:35,448 --> 01:07:38,288 He took her back to his house. Not home. 977 01:07:39,524 --> 01:07:42,687 There was a caravan on the site that he was living in. 978 01:07:43,427 --> 01:07:45,187 She went inside... 979 01:07:48,422 --> 01:07:50,426 ...and I believe that's where he killed her. 980 01:07:50,427 --> 01:07:52,155 Who is he? 981 01:07:52,678 --> 01:07:54,661 Where is he now? 982 01:08:01,938 --> 01:08:04,469 I'm about to do something really risky right now, Grace. 983 01:08:04,837 --> 01:08:06,373 What? 984 01:08:08,193 --> 01:08:10,499 I'm gonna go and arrest your mother's murderer. 985 01:08:11,637 --> 01:08:13,690 And I want you to be there for it. 986 01:08:22,888 --> 01:08:25,448 He's standing right there. Outside. 987 01:08:25,714 --> 01:08:27,187 He's here? 988 01:08:29,289 --> 01:08:30,998 He's standing right there. 989 01:08:38,157 --> 01:08:40,077 Approaching the building, over. 990 01:08:41,117 --> 01:08:42,357 Keep moving. 991 01:08:47,911 --> 01:08:50,111 The house is surrounded, Grace. 992 01:08:50,541 --> 01:08:52,861 They won't wait much longer before they come in here. 993 01:08:53,991 --> 01:08:55,271 Give me the gun. 994 01:08:55,303 --> 01:08:57,103 - We can do this together. - No. 995 01:08:59,249 --> 01:09:03,449 You go out there holding that, they're just gonna shoot you. 996 01:09:05,224 --> 01:09:07,080 You want answers, Grace. 997 01:09:08,452 --> 01:09:10,605 Please let me give them to you. 998 01:09:13,853 --> 01:09:15,121 He killed her? 999 01:09:15,430 --> 01:09:17,451 - Mm. - You're sure? 1000 01:09:19,738 --> 01:09:21,498 We have one chance. 1001 01:09:22,387 --> 01:09:25,827 Me and you. Are you coming or not? 1002 01:09:31,902 --> 01:09:36,156 I'm DS Karen Pirie. This woman is unarmed and the baby is safe. 1003 01:09:36,181 --> 01:09:37,426 Put the gun down. 1004 01:09:37,427 --> 01:09:40,238 I just need one minute, Ma'am. DS Pirie, put the gun down. 1005 01:09:40,239 --> 01:09:41,427 I just need one minute. 1006 01:09:41,810 --> 01:09:44,093 You need to stay there. No, you said... 1007 01:09:44,094 --> 01:09:45,586 I need you to trust me. 1008 01:09:45,587 --> 01:09:48,298 DS Pirie, put the gun down. I'm disarming the gun. 1009 01:09:52,438 --> 01:09:55,279 On the floor. Now look at me. Look at me. 1010 01:09:58,409 --> 01:10:00,948 Put the gun down now. 1011 01:10:04,861 --> 01:10:06,786 Walk towards me. 1012 01:10:06,787 --> 01:10:09,176 I just need you to give me one minute, Ma'am. 1013 01:10:12,923 --> 01:10:15,438 Sir, I need a word with you. 1014 01:10:16,500 --> 01:10:18,159 Are you all right, Sergeant? 1015 01:10:19,827 --> 01:10:23,030 Chief Superintendent James Lawson... 1016 01:10:25,847 --> 01:10:27,683 ...I am arresting you, 1017 01:10:27,684 --> 01:10:32,599 under section 1 of the Criminal Justice Scotland Act 2016... 1018 01:10:32,600 --> 01:10:33,760 What are you doing, Pirie? 1019 01:10:33,761 --> 01:10:36,982 ...for the murder... of Rosie Duff. 1020 01:10:36,983 --> 01:10:39,980 - This is ridiculous. - You are not obliged to say anything, 1021 01:10:39,981 --> 01:10:43,699 but anything you do say will be noted and may be used in evidence. 1022 01:10:43,700 --> 01:10:47,308 - You are embarrassing yourself, Sergeant. - Do you understand?! 1023 01:10:54,208 --> 01:10:56,111 Murray, you be careful now. 1024 01:10:56,318 --> 01:10:58,016 Don't you dare! 1025 01:10:58,017 --> 01:11:02,697 Forensics are on their way to Loch Leven right now. 1026 01:11:05,830 --> 01:11:08,014 We found the second crime scene. 1027 01:11:22,512 --> 01:11:25,526 Do you understand, Sir? 1028 01:11:55,401 --> 01:11:56,781 Grace Galloway, 1029 01:11:56,982 --> 01:12:01,022 I am arresting you under section 1 of the Criminal Justice Scotland Act 1030 01:12:01,186 --> 01:12:02,826 2016... 1031 01:12:03,776 --> 01:12:05,936 ...for the abduction of Davina Gilbey. 1032 01:12:28,346 --> 01:12:30,531 Chief Superintendent Lawson, 1033 01:12:30,946 --> 01:12:34,385 can you tell us, in your own words, where you were and what you did 1034 01:12:34,386 --> 01:12:38,026 on the night of 26th June 1996? 1035 01:12:43,426 --> 01:12:44,666 I'll ask you again. 1036 01:12:45,039 --> 01:12:48,700 Chief Superintendent Lawson, you were in St Andrews 1037 01:12:48,701 --> 01:12:54,381 at the Lammas Bar on the evening of 26th June 1996, were you not? 1038 01:12:57,727 --> 01:12:59,998 Perhaps I should tell you what I think happened. 1039 01:13:00,514 --> 01:13:03,817 Feel free to chip in anytime. 1040 01:13:05,316 --> 01:13:10,385 In around 1992, when you were 21 and Rosie Duff was 15 years old, 1041 01:13:10,386 --> 01:13:14,586 so still legally a child, you had a relationship with her. 1042 01:13:14,781 --> 01:13:17,506 I say relationship. It could have been a one-night stand, 1043 01:13:17,507 --> 01:13:19,851 but I imagine it was more significant then that 1044 01:13:19,852 --> 01:13:23,094 because of the possessiveness you displayed later, 1045 01:13:23,095 --> 01:13:25,426 as shown in Rosie's diary. 1046 01:13:26,537 --> 01:13:30,492 Can I prove all this? Well, I can prove one thing. 1047 01:13:31,297 --> 01:13:37,160 The DNA taken at your arrest is a close familial match with a woman 1048 01:13:37,161 --> 01:13:40,141 we have previously identified as Rosie Duff's child... 1049 01:13:41,399 --> 01:13:43,250 ...proving you are her father. 1050 01:13:45,079 --> 01:13:46,672 You were sleeping with Rosie 1051 01:13:46,673 --> 01:13:49,143 when she was underage and she got pregnant. 1052 01:13:49,626 --> 01:13:51,505 Of course, you couldn't have that coming out. 1053 01:13:51,506 --> 01:13:53,465 You were a young and ambitious policeman. 1054 01:13:53,466 --> 01:13:57,265 And, I'm guessing, but I don't think Rosie wanted a child either. 1055 01:13:57,266 --> 01:13:59,385 Maybe she was too far gone to have an abortion. 1056 01:13:59,386 --> 01:14:01,074 I don't know, I can't ask her. 1057 01:14:01,075 --> 01:14:05,010 But what did happen was that she went away for a summer, 1058 01:14:05,011 --> 01:14:08,200 to stay with an aunt, and had the baby in secret, 1059 01:14:08,201 --> 01:14:10,506 and told you and her family it had died. 1060 01:14:11,906 --> 01:14:13,254 But it didn't die. 1061 01:14:14,201 --> 01:14:18,303 That baby was a little girl. Your daughter. 1062 01:14:20,322 --> 01:14:23,645 She was adopted by Bonnie and Greg Galloway. 1063 01:14:24,192 --> 01:14:26,865 Grace Galloway is 27 now. 1064 01:14:26,866 --> 01:14:30,591 And she's been arrested for the murder of Ziggy Malkiewicz, 1065 01:14:30,592 --> 01:14:32,690 the attempted murder of Alex Gilbey 1066 01:14:32,691 --> 01:14:35,686 and the abduction of Alex Gilbey's child Davina. 1067 01:14:37,623 --> 01:14:41,370 You ruined your own daughter's life by not owning up. 1068 01:14:41,371 --> 01:14:44,185 She's gonna do a long stretch in prison, 1069 01:14:44,186 --> 01:14:46,084 and, don't get me wrong, she deserves it, 1070 01:14:46,561 --> 01:14:49,186 but you had a part to play in that, too. 1071 01:14:50,212 --> 01:14:51,681 So. Rosie. 1072 01:14:51,682 --> 01:14:54,305 I reckon she came back after her summer away 1073 01:14:54,306 --> 01:14:57,426 and you wanted everything to go back to normal. Am I right? 1074 01:14:57,838 --> 01:15:00,415 And I'm guessing Rosie didn't want that. 1075 01:15:00,771 --> 01:15:04,905 Maybe the trauma of it all had soured the relationship for her. 1076 01:15:04,906 --> 01:15:07,339 Maybe the way you acted had put her off you. 1077 01:15:07,364 --> 01:15:08,991 I don't know. I'm just guessing. 1078 01:15:10,768 --> 01:15:13,014 Maybe she was just never that into you. 1079 01:15:16,425 --> 01:15:18,536 But you weren't ready to give up, were you? 1080 01:15:18,758 --> 01:15:21,388 You kept your eyes on her at all times. 1081 01:15:22,109 --> 01:15:24,802 You drank in the Lammas Bar where she worked. 1082 01:15:24,827 --> 01:15:26,878 You made sure she didn't date anyone else. 1083 01:15:26,879 --> 01:15:29,563 You did this for three years. 1084 01:15:30,906 --> 01:15:32,426 A teenage girl. 1085 01:15:33,834 --> 01:15:35,986 Something told you she was moving on, didn't it? 1086 01:15:36,235 --> 01:15:38,305 You suspected it was one of the students, 1087 01:15:38,306 --> 01:15:39,866 but you never did know for sure. 1088 01:15:40,961 --> 01:15:44,281 And when Rosie snuck out the pub that night, you noticed. 1089 01:15:44,626 --> 01:15:46,306 You went looking for her. 1090 01:15:47,571 --> 01:15:52,552 And then, 2:15am on Prentiss Road. That's where you saw her. 1091 01:15:53,406 --> 01:15:56,269 - It's pissing it down, Rosie. - My brothers are picking me up. 1092 01:15:56,270 --> 01:15:57,418 Where from? I'll give you a lift. 1093 01:15:57,419 --> 01:16:00,036 No. You know they'll kill you, or me, if they see me with you. 1094 01:16:00,037 --> 01:16:03,449 - Just to the top of the street, then. - No, I'm all right. You go home. 1095 01:16:03,450 --> 01:16:06,369 - Where have you been? - I'm not doing this again. 1096 01:16:06,586 --> 01:16:08,145 Just talk to me, won't you? 1097 01:16:08,146 --> 01:16:10,138 - I don't want to talk to you. - Please, Rosie. 1098 01:16:10,139 --> 01:16:12,359 - You always say the same things. - Because I mean it. 1099 01:16:12,360 --> 01:16:14,105 It doesn't matter. We're over. 1100 01:16:14,106 --> 01:16:15,877 - We're done with. - You don't mean that. 1101 01:16:15,878 --> 01:16:17,854 It was just what happened. That ruined everything. 1102 01:16:17,855 --> 01:16:19,838 - Before that, we were fine. - Jimmy... 1103 01:16:19,839 --> 01:16:21,778 And now you're older, we don't have to hide it. 1104 01:16:21,779 --> 01:16:24,870 Jimmy, please. I don't want to talk about this. I just want to go home. 1105 01:16:24,871 --> 01:16:26,410 Let me give you a lift to the high street. 1106 01:16:26,411 --> 01:16:28,748 And I promise, I promise I'll leave it. 1107 01:16:28,749 --> 01:16:30,826 I cannae leave you out here in the rain. 1108 01:16:33,711 --> 01:16:36,791 But you didn't take her up to the high street, did you? 1109 01:16:36,986 --> 01:16:40,186 You took her back to your house. Your caravan. 1110 01:16:41,786 --> 01:16:46,282 Rosie had a rare paint on the hood of her cardigan 1111 01:16:46,559 --> 01:16:51,065 that matches the primer used on the inside of the door of your caravan. 1112 01:16:51,066 --> 01:16:53,105 So she obviously came inside. 1113 01:16:53,631 --> 01:16:55,304 Did she go willingly? 1114 01:16:56,703 --> 01:16:58,825 Did you tell her you'd stop bothering her 1115 01:16:58,826 --> 01:17:00,466 if she'd just talk to you? 1116 01:17:01,264 --> 01:17:04,321 Did you say you'd take her home if she just gave you five minutes? 1117 01:17:06,106 --> 01:17:10,139 I know you had sex. I think you forced it on her. 1118 01:17:10,430 --> 01:17:13,845 And I think when she told you to stop, you got angry. 1119 01:17:14,341 --> 01:17:16,801 You put your hands around her neck. 1120 01:17:18,418 --> 01:17:19,955 And you strangled her. 1121 01:17:21,620 --> 01:17:25,535 You strangled that poor girl until she was unconscious. 1122 01:17:25,866 --> 01:17:27,474 And then you panicked. 1123 01:17:28,146 --> 01:17:29,985 Maybe you didn't mean to kill her. 1124 01:17:29,986 --> 01:17:31,907 Maybe you just wanted to teach her a lesson. 1125 01:17:32,146 --> 01:17:34,614 Show her how strong you were. How small she was. 1126 01:17:34,615 --> 01:17:37,544 I know you weren't thinking straight because the truth was... 1127 01:17:38,186 --> 01:17:39,683 she wasn't dead. 1128 01:17:40,318 --> 01:17:42,596 And you didn't take the time to check. 1129 01:17:43,191 --> 01:17:45,584 You thought of yourself before her. You didn't think, 1130 01:17:45,585 --> 01:17:47,905 "How can I save this girl from what I've done to her?" 1131 01:17:47,906 --> 01:17:50,639 You thought, "How can I make it look as though it wasn't me?" 1132 01:17:51,146 --> 01:17:54,225 You thought of the other unsolved murders that you'd heard of. 1133 01:17:54,226 --> 01:17:56,625 The one in Inverurie came to mind, 1134 01:17:56,626 --> 01:17:59,763 a girl left in a cemetery, cut across the stomach. 1135 01:18:00,869 --> 01:18:05,102 I think you took a kitchen knife from your caravan, 1136 01:18:05,386 --> 01:18:09,745 you put her in the boot of your car and you drove her to the cathedral. 1137 01:18:09,746 --> 01:18:12,459 You laid her out on a grave, and you cut her, 1138 01:18:13,106 --> 01:18:14,901 to tie the two crimes together. 1139 01:18:16,136 --> 01:18:18,124 And she died there... 1140 01:18:19,677 --> 01:18:21,002 ...slowly. 1141 01:18:22,298 --> 01:18:24,686 Whilst you went home and cleaned yourself up. 1142 01:18:27,157 --> 01:18:30,145 You were back at the crime scene within 45 minutes, 1143 01:18:30,146 --> 01:18:31,625 after MacLennan called you. 1144 01:18:31,626 --> 01:18:33,667 You were relieved when the students found her. 1145 01:18:33,668 --> 01:18:36,519 That's when you first knew you might get away with it. 1146 01:18:36,881 --> 01:18:38,376 When you took over the case, 1147 01:18:38,377 --> 01:18:41,109 you made a whole box of evidence go missing. 1148 01:18:41,254 --> 01:18:43,934 All of Rosie's clothes. Genius. 1149 01:18:44,692 --> 01:18:46,532 How would we ever connect you now? 1150 01:18:46,986 --> 01:18:50,225 What you didn't account for was human error, 1151 01:18:50,226 --> 01:18:52,867 because Rosie's cardigan was genuinely misfiled, 1152 01:18:52,868 --> 01:18:56,066 and that is where we found the paint. 1153 01:18:56,972 --> 01:18:58,859 You thought you'd dealt with the eyewitness. 1154 01:18:58,860 --> 01:19:02,158 The eyewitness that saw Rosie getting into your car. 1155 01:19:04,906 --> 01:19:07,870 Was it your car, DCS Lawson? 1156 01:19:08,831 --> 01:19:10,543 Or was it your mother's car? 1157 01:19:11,709 --> 01:19:15,706 Did you use your mum's car to dispose of a body? 1158 01:19:18,379 --> 01:19:21,345 You sold it a week later, bought her a new one. 1159 01:19:21,346 --> 01:19:22,388 She was delighted. 1160 01:19:24,906 --> 01:19:27,389 This next part, I'm not so sure on. 1161 01:19:27,390 --> 01:19:29,306 Maybe you can help me. 1162 01:19:30,287 --> 01:19:31,509 MacLennan. 1163 01:19:32,906 --> 01:19:36,306 He knew about this eyewitness, but he didn't share it with you. 1164 01:19:36,626 --> 01:19:38,384 He told Janice. 1165 01:19:38,706 --> 01:19:40,505 And she mentioned it to you. 1166 01:19:40,506 --> 01:19:43,039 I've been going through his notes, 1167 01:19:43,226 --> 01:19:46,037 trying to find details of this eyewitness. 1168 01:19:46,038 --> 01:19:47,407 I know, me, too. 1169 01:19:47,408 --> 01:19:50,182 There's a few scribbled phone numbers, 1170 01:19:50,183 --> 01:19:51,673 but none of them have been right. 1171 01:19:51,701 --> 01:19:53,442 But he must have had it down somewhere. 1172 01:19:53,443 --> 01:19:55,409 Leave it with me. I'm gonna stay late, I think. 1173 01:19:55,410 --> 01:19:57,628 Is that because he was already onto you? 1174 01:19:58,158 --> 01:19:59,985 Did you know that, somehow? 1175 01:19:59,986 --> 01:20:01,881 Because it's just weird, isn't it, 1176 01:20:01,882 --> 01:20:04,192 that a detective is about to solve a crime, 1177 01:20:04,193 --> 01:20:06,135 and then dies in an accident? 1178 01:20:06,136 --> 01:20:08,409 An accident that you were present for? 1179 01:20:08,410 --> 01:20:10,074 Barney! 1180 01:20:11,604 --> 01:20:13,188 Jimmy... 1181 01:20:15,386 --> 01:20:16,906 I can't see you! 1182 01:20:41,427 --> 01:20:43,067 Did you kill MacLennan? 1183 01:20:44,181 --> 01:20:47,365 Did you kill him before he could tell anyone what you did? 1184 01:20:47,466 --> 01:20:48,478 No. 1185 01:20:50,577 --> 01:20:52,009 It was an accident. 1186 01:20:52,427 --> 01:20:54,004 I couldn't save him. 1187 01:20:54,506 --> 01:20:56,106 I tried to. 1188 01:21:00,026 --> 01:21:02,807 So everything else I've said... 1189 01:21:04,658 --> 01:21:06,456 ...is not worth a response? 1190 01:21:07,386 --> 01:21:08,707 But that? 1191 01:21:11,551 --> 01:21:13,151 That was too far? 1192 01:21:20,372 --> 01:21:22,800 I underestimated you, Karen Pirie. 1193 01:21:26,559 --> 01:21:28,399 Is that why you gave me the job? 1194 01:21:30,638 --> 01:21:32,157 You thought I couldn't do it. 1195 01:21:33,266 --> 01:21:35,186 You were sure I'd never do it. 1196 01:21:41,257 --> 01:21:42,737 I did. 1197 01:21:49,500 --> 01:21:50,866 I... 1198 01:21:51,238 --> 01:21:54,925 had always imagined what my birth mother looked like. 1199 01:21:55,709 --> 01:21:57,847 Dark eyes like mine. 1200 01:21:59,305 --> 01:22:00,746 Dark hair. 1201 01:22:01,870 --> 01:22:04,432 Beautiful, of course, because... 1202 01:22:05,257 --> 01:22:09,341 that's just how you imagine someone you love but have never met. 1203 01:22:11,335 --> 01:22:13,229 And then the podcast came out. 1204 01:22:14,496 --> 01:22:19,460 At first, I thought it was on my side, that it was going to help her. 1205 01:22:20,870 --> 01:22:22,836 That it was going to help me. 1206 01:22:25,307 --> 01:22:27,746 And I started to read the messages... 1207 01:22:29,122 --> 01:22:32,724 ...and look at the crime scene photos that were shared on there. 1208 01:22:34,531 --> 01:22:36,106 Photos of her... 1209 01:22:38,186 --> 01:22:42,014 ...of her pale face and her neck... 1210 01:22:42,692 --> 01:22:44,560 and the blood on her clothes... 1211 01:22:44,561 --> 01:22:47,308 and I stopped being able to see her any more. 1212 01:22:48,407 --> 01:22:50,502 The version of my mum I had in my head. 1213 01:22:50,503 --> 01:22:53,186 I started to see all this stuff instead. 1214 01:22:56,360 --> 01:22:59,699 This lifeless body. 1215 01:22:59,700 --> 01:23:02,640 Because that's what she was to the world. 1216 01:23:02,978 --> 01:23:06,140 A dead girl. A body. 1217 01:23:09,266 --> 01:23:11,124 And, suddenly, I just wanted to see them. 1218 01:23:11,125 --> 01:23:12,821 I just wanted to see... 1219 01:23:15,186 --> 01:23:16,774 ...who killed her. 1220 01:23:17,513 --> 01:23:21,511 So, when they were named on these forums, 1221 01:23:22,188 --> 01:23:23,558 I believed it... 1222 01:23:24,631 --> 01:23:27,186 ...and I went and I found them. 1223 01:23:28,546 --> 01:23:30,194 And I followed them. 1224 01:23:37,106 --> 01:23:39,052 But when I saw their... 1225 01:23:40,238 --> 01:23:45,225 ...big houses and their... careers and their... 1226 01:23:46,595 --> 01:23:48,839 marriages and their babies... 1227 01:23:50,695 --> 01:23:52,506 ...I got so angry. 1228 01:23:54,186 --> 01:23:58,102 Because she was never going to have any of that. 1229 01:24:00,175 --> 01:24:02,615 Because it was all snatched from her. 1230 01:24:06,946 --> 01:24:08,391 I won't... 1231 01:24:09,489 --> 01:24:14,025 I won't make excuses. I won't... I won't justify. 1232 01:24:16,479 --> 01:24:22,108 I... I made a split-second decision to end a man's life. 1233 01:24:23,848 --> 01:24:25,395 The wrong man's life. 1234 01:24:43,946 --> 01:24:46,226 And I will never forgive myself. 1235 01:24:47,906 --> 01:24:49,546 Because I'm just like him. 1236 01:24:52,866 --> 01:24:54,936 There is a difference, Grace. 1237 01:24:57,706 --> 01:24:59,426 You confessed. 1238 01:25:02,420 --> 01:25:03,880 He didn't? 1239 01:25:13,971 --> 01:25:15,531 Do you want to meet him? 1240 01:25:19,000 --> 01:25:20,186 No. 1241 01:25:21,193 --> 01:25:24,433 I want him to spend the rest of his life wondering what I'm like. 1242 01:25:29,155 --> 01:25:30,826 Just like I have to do with her. 1243 01:25:33,254 --> 01:25:34,794 Hiya. Hi. 1244 01:25:35,629 --> 01:25:36,837 I'm Colin. 1245 01:25:38,434 --> 01:25:39,636 Hi, Colin. 1246 01:25:39,637 --> 01:25:40,751 Hi. 1247 01:25:48,260 --> 01:25:49,429 Pirie. 1248 01:25:52,666 --> 01:25:53,695 Sir. 1249 01:25:54,984 --> 01:25:59,136 "Bittersweet" doesn't quite cut it, does it? 1250 01:26:01,586 --> 01:26:03,826 No, Sir. 1251 01:26:05,537 --> 01:26:09,044 It's a hard thing, taking down one of your own. 1252 01:26:09,541 --> 01:26:13,365 Unsettles the whole place. Puts everybody's eyes on you. 1253 01:26:15,395 --> 01:26:16,928 And because of that, 1254 01:26:17,488 --> 01:26:21,108 it takes bravery and it takes guts. 1255 01:26:22,645 --> 01:26:25,664 You are an asset to this service, Karen. 1256 01:26:27,706 --> 01:26:28,889 Thank you, Sir. 1257 01:26:29,226 --> 01:26:30,590 You're welcome. 1258 01:26:31,158 --> 01:26:32,349 Back to work. 1259 01:26:55,226 --> 01:26:57,745 'How much more chilling is it to know 1260 01:26:57,746 --> 01:27:02,037 'that this tragic killing was committed by a police officer? 1261 01:27:02,604 --> 01:27:05,191 'Someone who we should feel safe around. 1262 01:27:05,426 --> 01:27:08,178 'Someone employed to protect us. 1263 01:27:08,890 --> 01:27:13,300 'The Duff family finally have answers. They can finally heal. 1264 01:27:13,794 --> 01:27:16,096 'But the Scottish Police Service 1265 01:27:16,139 --> 01:27:20,515 'may feel the ripples of this trauma for a long time.' 1266 01:27:48,284 --> 01:27:50,625 So, not The Box-Ticker any more, eh? 1267 01:27:50,626 --> 01:27:51,703 Box-Ticker? 1268 01:27:52,148 --> 01:27:54,104 Don't even start. No. 1269 01:27:54,518 --> 01:27:56,665 You're gonna need a new nickname, though. 1270 01:27:56,666 --> 01:27:58,905 I was thinking... Pirie Pirie Sauce. 1271 01:27:58,906 --> 01:28:00,025 Too long. 1272 01:28:00,026 --> 01:28:03,127 Hot Sauce. I like Hot Sauce. 1273 01:28:03,128 --> 01:28:05,711 No-one's gonna call you Hot Sauce in the office. 1274 01:28:05,712 --> 01:28:07,280 Mmm. I might. 1275 01:28:09,906 --> 01:28:11,238 Fanny Pack? 1276 01:28:12,103 --> 01:28:13,576 Absolutely not. 1277 01:28:14,170 --> 01:28:16,345 Right, I'm off. 1278 01:28:16,346 --> 01:28:17,506 Oh, I have... 1279 01:28:20,254 --> 01:28:23,111 I'm gonna... get one more. 1280 01:28:26,494 --> 01:28:29,974 - You following me? - Would you mind very much if I was? 1281 01:28:29,975 --> 01:28:32,728 Ah. Depends on what you want. 1282 01:28:32,729 --> 01:28:36,606 I just want to keep you safe... from criminals. 1283 01:28:36,607 --> 01:28:38,746 I'm better at that than you, remember. 1284 01:28:38,747 --> 01:28:41,362 Ah... OK. 1285 01:28:49,220 --> 01:28:55,220 Subtitle extracted & improved by Se7enOfNin9 for Addic7ed.com